Best Suburbs in Fort Myers for Singles & Young Professionals in 2024

Relocating to Fort Myers? The City of Palms is a great place for young adults to live, thanks to its incredible year-round weather, beach access, cool hangout spots, and more. If you’re looking for somewhere to settle down, here are the best Fort Myers suburbs for singles and young professionals!

Buckingham

  • Home Price: $236,000 median purchase price; $968 median monthly rent
  • Crime Rate: Safer than 68% of Florida cities

Not only is Buckingham a popular neighborhood for Fort Myers families, but singles and young professionals are also drawn to the area for its plentiful outdoor recreation opportunities. Nature lovers have lots to explore in this Fort Myers suburb, whether it’s hiking at Harns Marsh Preserve, attending events at the Calusa Nature Center & Planetarium, or going fishing and paddling at the nearby Hickey Creek Wildlife & Environmental Area. While Buckingham’s many green spaces and rural community give it a small-town atmosphere, it’s located within minutes of big city amenities and also offers great local nightlife. If you’re looking to plant roots here, you’ll find condos and ranches along with new construction and Mediterranean homes boasting spacious yards.

Things to Do in Buckingham

Enjoy an afternoon outdoors while playing football or baseball on the fields at Buckingham Community Park. View the manatees during the cooler months, rent a kayak, or go fishing on the waterfront at Manatee Park. Go for a hike and observe the flora and fauna at Six Mile Cypress Preserve North. Play a game of pickleball or play 18 holes of golf in Fort Myers—on the scenic course designed by professional golfer Jack Nicklaus—when you become a member at Verandah Club. Indulge in farm-to-table dishes like a Crab Cake BLT, Pork Tacos, or the Barn Yard Chicken Sandwich at Buckingham Farms. Listen to local bands and order savory plates like the Blackened Mahi Mahi Sandwich, Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap, or Chopped Steak at Rum Bucket Bar & Grill. Dine on Italian cuisine made with local ingredients like the Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo, Three Cheese Ravioli, or Creamy Italian Sausage at Casa D’Italia. Grab a seat on the patio and try the Pork Sandwich or Chicken Tenders with an Amber Bock draft at the country-style hangout, Buckingham Blues Bar.

Search Form Find an Extra Space Storage facility near you
Search

Gateway

  • Home Price: $274,200 median purchase price; $1,348 median monthly rent
  • Crime Rate: Safer than 74% of Florida cities

Known best for its welcoming community and top-rated golf course The Club at Gateway, Gateway is a popular place to land among young professionals. In this Fort Myers suburb, residents can choose from a wide array of housing types—like bungalows, ranches, townhouses, and condos—surrounded by unique recreational amenities, including a community pool, dog park, playground, and more. Especially active residents will appreciate Gateway’s variety of parks and trails, along with sports courts and parks scattered throughout the area—such as Gateway Neighborhood Park. Gateway is also a convenient option for frequent commuters, as it’s located near both I-75 and the Southwest Florida International Airport, providing quick access to major nearby cities and beyond!

Things to Do in Gateway

Challenge yourself to a game of tennis or bocce ball, practice your golf swing on the driving range, or hit up the resort-style pool when you become a member at The Club at Gateway. Spend a day bird-watching, hiking in Fort Myers, or observing wildlife at Wild Turkey Strand Preserve. Grab tickets to watch the Boston Red Sox (MLB) during spring training at JetBlue Park. Start off your day with breakfast favorites like Jujo’s Breakfast Tacos, a Bistro Benedict, or New Yorker Hash at Skinny Dogz Brunchery. Satisfy your tastebuds with Pad Thai, Stir Fry, or Teriyaki Chicken for lunch at neighborhood favorite Rock’n Sushi. Watch a game on the big screen and try a Southwest Salad or Triple Turkey Club with a 420 Extra Pale Ale at Boulevard Deli & Tavern. Chow down Italian-inspired eats like Fried Calamari, Margherita Pizza, or Veal Marsala at The Saucy Meatball. Or enjoy Mexican dishes like Fajitas, a Torta Asada, or a Vegetarian Quesadilla at Casa Lupita Cafe.

McGregor

  • Home Price: $276,400 median purchase price; $1,097 median monthly rent
  • Crime Rate: Safer than 78% of Florida cities

Situated on the banks of the Caloosahatchee River, McGregor is one of the best places to live in Fort Myers for singles and young professionals thanks in part to its proximity to the beach. Not only do residents have easy access to waterfront activities like kayaking, canoeing, and boating, but those living in McGregor can also travel to Downtown Fort Myers or Cape Coral via historic McGregor Blvd or Cape Coral Bridge for even more fun. However, young adults don’t have to venture far to find fun things to do—this Fort Myers suburb offers live entertainment, local shops, delicious restaurants, bustling bars, and more! And amongst large palm trees lining the streets, those looking for a home in McGregor will find housing options ranging from condos and townhouses, to Spanish-style estates and newly-constructed waterfront properties.

Things to Do in McGregor

Watch the sunset, host an outdoor BBQ, or go for a walk at the serene Picnic Pointe. Spend an an afternoon shopping for antique furniture, home decor, accessories, and other vintage items at Farmhouse 44. Support local arts by attending shows like Breaking Legs, Butterflies Are Free, and Godspell at Players Circle Theater. Gather your friends for karaoke on Wednesdays or watch live rock band performances at Buddha LIVE. Choose from breakfast options like the Farmer Frittata Melt, Vegan Tofu Scramble Wrap, or Blueberry Pancakes at The Speckled Egg Cafe. Get your fill of Greek food with the Greek Chicken Salad, Greek Chow Mein, or a Gyro at Nomiki’s Plakka Greek Restaurant. Savor dishes like the Pear & Blue Salad, Monte Cristo Sandwich, or BLT at CRaVE Restaurant. Or enjoy date night while sipping speciality cocktails like the Strawberry Gin Tini, Sangria, or Vodka Gimlet at CIBO.

San Carlos Park

  • Home Price: $127,000 median purchase price; $1,065 median monthly rent
  • Crime Rate: Safer than 30% of Florida cities

Looking for a bustling Fort Myers suburb with plenty of amenities? Check out San Carlos Park! With Florida Gulf Coast University just across I-75, this suburb is a great place for singles and young professionals looking to further their studies, work in education, or attend exciting FGCU athletics games. On top of that, sports enthusiasts can also play everything from baseball to pickleball and volleyball, and more at nearby Three Oaks Park. Looking for nightlife near Fort Myers? Check out the entertainment and socialization options at Gulf Coast Town Center—and attend events like the Thursday Night Concert Series! Additionally, this affordable Fort Myers suburb offers a mixture of housing options that range from condos to spacious ranches and Craftsman-style homes.

Things to Do in San Carlos Park

Schedule a tee time at 18-hole championship course, San Carlos Golf Club—one of the oldest golf clubs in Southwest Florida. Cool off during the summer months by taking a dip in the water, swimming laps, or attending Water Aerobics at the San Carlos Community Pool. Go rock climbing or take a Bouldering Class at the indoor Fort Rock Climbing Center. Spend the day shopping, dining, and playing games—or bring your furry pal to Barktober Fest at the Gulf Coast Town Center. Order Eggplant Rollatini, Chicken Siciliana, Sausage Pizzaiola, and more at the Sicily-inspired Nino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant. Grab a Chili & Cheese Dog, “Authentic” Chicago Style Dog, or a Hamburger for dinner at Matt’s Red Hots. Get your dessert fix with a scoop of Cherry Oblivion, a Banana Split, or Cookie Dough Shake at San Carlos Scoops. Or sample tap beers like the Ocean View Pilsner, Beach Lager, or Quiet Storm IPA at Palm City Brewing Co.

Whiskey Creek

  • Home Price: $203,300 median purchase price; $1,090 median monthly rent
  • Crime Rate: Safer than 68% of Florida cities

For a residential area near Fort Myers, Whiskey Creek offers residents plenty to do! This suburb’s housing options range from dock-accessible waterfront condos and houses, to Mid-Century Modern ranches—at budget-friendly rates. But what really draws young adults to this Fort Myers suburb is the big-town amenities with the small-town vibe! With the local Pine Manor Community Center providing programs and a community garden, and theaters, restaurants, and bars nearby—there’s always something to do in this Fort Myers suburb. Not to mention, the Caloosahatchee River offers outdoor activities like paddleboarding, kayaking, fishing, and more!

Things to Do in Whiskey Creek

Ride your bike, play basketball with friends, or jog at Hunter Park. Grab tickets to popular shows like Elvis: A Musical Revolution or Broadway’s Hairspray at Broadway Palm Dinner Theatre. Stroll through the Night Market, attend the annual Rocky Horror Picture Show outdoor movie event, or sign up for a painting class at Alliance for the Arts. Participate in social events like card games on weekdays or play golf at the Whiskey Creek Golf Club. Fill up on Chicken Tortilla Soup, Coconut Shrimp Tacos, or Clancey’s Fish and Chips at the old fashioned eatery, Whiskey Creek Station. Pick up Italian dishes like White Lasagna, Cheese Ravioli, or Bolognese for dinner at Buon Appetito Cafe. Enjoy plates like Prime Rib, Wagyu Strip Steak, or Ahi Tuna at casual KJ’s Steakhouse. Or try the Southern Rice Bowl, Grilled Chicken Breast, or Caesar Salad at Patinella’s Chicken Grill.

***

Moving to Fort Myers? Extra Space Storage has convenient storage facilities located throughout the Fort Myers area, so we help with your transition. Find a storage facility near you!

Suburb statistics from AreaVibes.

About Mike Beutler

Mike Beutler is a writer and digital content specialist who transitioned to self storage in 2020 after several years in the airline industry. His travels cultivated a passion for exploring cities across the U.S. and abroad and inspired him to learn more about practical insights for urban living. With 14 moves under his belt, both locally and cross-country, he also has a passion for minimalism and organization, and sharing tips to help others make any space feel like home while staying organized.

Share

Recent Posts

District Manager Kent McKenzie Retires after 28 Years at Extra Space Storage

Please join Extra Space Storage in congratulating Kent McKenzie, who is retiring from Extra Space…

Jun 13, 2024

9 Best Places to Get Free & Cheap Moving Boxes in The Bronx

Moving to Bronx, NY? Between hiring movers and buying moving supplies, moving costs can add…

Jun 12, 2024

11 Best Places to Get Free & Cheap Moving Boxes in Denver

Are you moving out of state or relocating across town in Denver? Whether you're moving…

Jun 12, 2024

10 Best Places to Get Free & Cheap Moving Boxes in Indianapolis

Whether you're moving across the country or to a new Indianapolis neighborhood—moving costs can add…

Jun 11, 2024

10 Best Places to Get Free & Cheap Moving Boxes in Sacramento

Moving out of state or relocating locally? No matter how far you're going, moving costs…

Jun 11, 2024

9 Best Places to Get Free & Cheap Moving Boxes in Atlanta

Whether you're moving out of Atlanta or moving locally, moving costs can start to add…

Jun 11, 2024