Cities and suburbs each have their share of advantages and disadvantages, but how do you decide where the best place to raise a family is? We’ve compiled a few pros and cons of urban vs. suburban living to help you make the right choice for your family!
City vs. Suburbs at a Glance
Choosing between city and suburban living comes down to what works for your family’s budget, lifestyle, and priorities. Compare the differences between the two to see which option better fits the needs of your family.
| Factor | Living in the City | Living in the Suburbs |
| Cost of Living | Higher costs for amenities like dining & entertainment | Everyday expenses may be lower, though families often spend more money on gas & commuting |
| Cost of Housing | Homes & apartments tend to be more expensive | Homes tend to be larger with smaller price tags |
| Living Space | Apartments, condos, & smaller homes with less storage space | Larger homes, yards, & garages, plus more storage space |
| Education | Access to public, private, & even specialized schools | Families generally have access to large school districts |
| Commute | Shorter commutes and potential public transit options for families without cars | Longer commutes & greater dependence on cars |
| Diversity & Culture | Restaurants, museums, local events, & cultural activities are close by | Cultural amenities are more spread out, but restaurants, events, & more may still be nearby |
The Real Cost Difference in 2026
The cost of living often varies between a city and its suburbs. Suburban housing is generally more affordable per square foot than housing near a city’s downtown or other highly concentrated urban areas—but total costs can vary widely depending on your specific metro. In particularly large metros, suburbs tend to be less expensive, but for smaller metros, housing in the suburbs may be more expensive, mainly because housing sizes trend larger. Additionally, families with children can find lower childcare costs in the suburbs vs. the city. However, city living can offer some savings in other important areas. Urban buildings tend to be more energy-efficient because their compact construction helps with insulation, which means a lower utility bill. And living in the city often means your family can walk and utilize public transportation, potentially saving you upwards of $13,000 per year on car payments, insurance, maintenance costs, and gas.
Raising Kids in the City
If you already love city life, there’s a good chance you’ll love it with kids too. Most of what draws you to the city now carries over to family life, though a few trade-offs become more noticeable once kids are in the picture.
Pros of City Living for Families
From built-in culture to shorter commutes, here’s what city living offers families.
Abundant Entertainment Options
A major advantage of raising children in the city is the easy access to after-school or weekend activities. Movie theaters, parks, museums, galleries, and festivals are all fun ways for kids and parents to enjoy themselves outside the home. Plus, entertainment districts are often within walking distance.
Exposure to Diversity
Another big difference in raising your family in the city is diversity—city centers tend to draw in people of all different cultural, ethnic, economic, and religious backgrounds. As the U.S. becomes more diverse, most of the country’s biggest cities have grown more racially diverse as well. Because of this, your child is more likely to be exposed to a variety of people and experiences. Major cities also offer cultural events as well as different types of food and languages for you and your family to enjoy.
Greater Access to Food Items
One of the advantages of living in the city is most urban areas have small businesses and a greater variety of grocery stores to choose from, which means more product variety at competitive prices. Grocery shopping in the city can be more convenient, too, with nearby locations and later hours. Plus, more food and grocery delivery services are readily offered in large cities, so you can expect faster delivery times than in the suburbs!
Shorter Commutes
One of the biggest perks of city living is how close everything is. Instead of spending an hour or more in traffic each day, your commute might be a quick walk, bike ride, or train trip, which means more time at home with your family. Shorter distances also make it easier to fit school drop-offs, pediatrician appointments, and after-school activities into a busy day. And even if you work remotely, having schools, parks, and errands just a few blocks away keeps the whole family’s daily trips short.
Excellent Walkability
If you have children in the city and live in a walkable neighborhood, your daily routine doubles as a chance to stay active. A walk to school, the park, or the corner store adds movement to your family’s day without requiring you to set aside extra time for it. Getting around on foot also makes spontaneous outings easier. And because you won’t need to drive everywhere, many city families find they can get by with one car or none at all, saving money on gas, parking, insurance, and maintenance.
Kids Have More Independence
Kids in the city are given the opportunity to become more independent from a younger age. As your children get older, the city’s walkability and public transportation will allow them to be more independent and get around the city on their own. This means you won’t need to chauffeur your child to every after-school event or hangout.
Smaller Home Means Less Clutter
Living in the city usually means raising a family in a smaller space, and that can work in your favor, especially if you’re trying to minimize clutter. Furnishing and decorating an apartment also takes less time and money than filling an entire house. Plus, with less to clean and maintain, you’ll have more time to get out and experience everything the city has to offer.
Cons of City Living for Families
While there’s certainly a strong argument for raising kids in the city, remember to weigh these drawbacks before you commit.
Competition for School Spots
Cities are home to many great schools, but getting into them isn’t always easy. The top public schools in big cities are often zoned for higher-cost neighborhoods, and even in a strong district, overcrowding can limit available spots. Some magnet and specialty schools also rely on applications or lotteries, so it helps to research your options and deadlines early. Zoning and competition can also contribute to broader inequality, and many city public schools remain segregated by race and income.
Lack of Private Outdoor Space
City living generally requires tighter quarters, making it difficult to find a home with ample outdoor living spaces that are private and quickly accessible. And when you have restless kids or pets who need to run around, that can be a problem.
Might Not Be Allowed to Have Pets
Depending on where your family lives, you may not be permitted to have pets when you choose live in the city. If you do find an apartment or condo building where pets are allowed, there may be breed and weight restrictions, plus a costly pet deposit and monthly animal fees.
Loud Atmosphere
Police sirens, rowdy nightlife seekers, honking traffic—these are just a few noises your family will have to get used to while living in the city. This can make it difficult to keep quiet hours in your home which, in turn, can disrupt your kids’ sleep schedule.
Parental Tasks May Be More Difficult
Washing your clothing at the laundromat might not be inconvenient for just one person, but an entire family’s laundry is another story. Raising kids is messy, and having in-unit laundry can be a luxury in the city. Even shopping for groceries or school supplies can be trickier, especially if you’re carrying everything home on foot or public transit instead of loading up a car. This means you might have to be more strategic about how much you buy or take multiple trips to get everything you need. Even if you’re able to buy items in bulk, you’re less likely to have enough space to store them.
Parking Can Be a Challenge
If your family does have a car or two, parking can be a hassle. Some apartments don’t offer off-street parking, making it even more difficult to get children where they need to go. If you’re planning to keep your vehicle while living in the city, you’ll need to factor parking costs into your budget.
Raising Kids in the Suburbs
There’s a reason the suburbs are synonymous with family life. More space, strong schools, and close-knit neighborhoods top the list, but suburban living has its own compromises.
Pros of Suburban Living for Families
Here’s why so many families make the move outside the city.
More House for the Money
In many metro areas, what you’d pay for a condo in the city could buy a house in the suburbs. Depending on where you look, the same budget can get you substantially more living space outside the city, making it more affordable for families to own a larger home with a yard.
More Room for Amenities
Raising a child in the suburbs often means having more amenities at home. In-unit laundry, a dishwasher, and additional storage space can be harder to find in a city apartment but are usually standard in a suburban house. This added convenience can make everyday family life a little easier.
Space for a Home Office
Remote work can make living in suburbia more appealing for families who want to avoid a long daily commute. When looking for a home, think about how much space you’ll need for work, whether that’s an extra bedroom for a home office or at least a dedicated workspace. Having a separate workspace can make it easier to focus, especially when your kids are too young for school or have a day off.
Access to Great Schools
Moving to the suburbs can mean easier access to good schools. While there are great schools in cities, suburbs are often designed with families in mind, meaning residents may end up living next to a school or very close by to the neighborhood school.
Peace & Quiet
One of the advantages of living in a suburb is quieter streets. Suburbs don’t have the loud noises of the city that might otherwise keep your family up at night. Living in a house instead of an apartment also means you don’t have to share walls, so you rarely hear your neighbors.
Close-Knit Neighborhoods
Another benefit of living in the suburbs is the opportunity to connect with your neighbors. Your children will most likely attend the same school or daycare as other children in your neighborhood, so it’s easy to make friends. Suburbs also typically have lots of families with young children, meaning playdates, babysitters, or lunchtime companions are nearby. It might also be easier for parents to make friends with other parents and build a community in the suburbs with community events like farmers markets and festivals.
Guaranteed Parking
Easy parking is another advantage of living in the suburbs. With a garage and a driveway, you don’t have to worry about finding parking on the street, and you won’t have to bother scraping your windows in the winter. You won’t have to leave your house earlier to allow time for finding parking at most suburban destinations, either.
Cons of Suburban Living for Families
Suburban life isn’t perfect—here are a few of the downsides to consider before making your decision.
Lack of Entertainment & Food Options
A major difference between urban and suburban living is the proximity to activities and restaurant options. The suburbs can be just far enough from the excitement of the city that driving to museums, theaters, and diverse dining can be an inconvenience.
Less Diversity
While it isn’t true of every suburban neighborhood, city living generally provides more opportunities for kids to meet people from a wide range of backgrounds. Suburbs are becoming increasingly diverse, but many are still less diverse than nearby cities, so your kids may spend more of their time around people with backgrounds similar to their own.
Less Walkability
Though there are walkable neighborhoods in the suburbs with quiet streets and lots of sidewalks, they tend to be sprawled out, meaning it’s not as easy to walk to the grocery store, pharmacy, school, library, or community events. This means errands are more of a hassle, and your children may have less independence as well.
Higher Transportation Costs
As your kids get older and become involved in sports and other activities outside your immediate area, commute times in the suburbs and driving costs could increase exponentially. Weekend trips to the zoo or parks will also take longer, require more gas, and put more miles on your vehicle. Plus, keep in mind that public school transportation is not always a given with school bus shortages.
Higher Risk of Car Accidents
Suburban families usually spend more time on the road, and all that extra driving comes with added risk. Cities often have a reputation for being less safe because of higher crime rates in some areas, but public transportation is safer than traveling by car. Once you add up the school runs, errands, and activities that require a car in the suburbs, the greater chance of a traffic accident is worth weighing.
Larger Carbon Footprint
Living in the suburbs often comes with a larger carbon footprint. Limited public transportation, bigger homes that take more energy to heat and cool, and longer distances between home, work, activities, and errands all contribute to higher carbon emissions. City dwellers, on the other hand, tend to have lower emissions because walkable neighborhoods and better transit make it easier to drive less.
Home Maintenance Costs
A hidden suburban cost you may not think about is home maintenance. Homeowners should budget 1-4% of their home value for annual home upkeep and maintenance. Don’t forget any Homeowners Association (HOA) fees you might also have to pay in the suburbs, as well as extra costs like lawn care that may come along with being in an HOA.
What Should Factor Into Your Family’s Decision?
When deciding between city and suburban living for your family, there’s no single right answer. The best choice depends on your family’s specific needs, priorities, and stage of life. Here are some final considerations to help make the best choice for your family.
Consider Your Kids’ Ages
The ages of your children can influence whether you’d be better off living in the city vs. the suburbs. Younger children and toddlers may benefit more from suburban space, a quieter neighborhood, and stable schools. On the other hand, teens may benefit more from the independence and access to internships, arts, entertainment, and social activities that living in the city can offer. Regardless of your choice, the most important thing to consider is what will work for your family over the next several years—not just immediate needs.
Recognize Your Family’s Lifestyle
Whether you should live in the suburbs or the city depends on what matters most to your family. Parents who work remotely and have younger kids may appreciate the extra room the suburbs offer for working and spending time together, while families who value walkability and having activities close by may prefer the city. Dual-income households focused on high-quality schools may find the suburbs offer the space and family-friendly amenities they need. And for families who prioritize culture and diversity, city living offers easier access to diverse communities, museums, the arts, and cultural events.
Plan for the Space Trade-Off
Whether you’re relocating to a large city in a new state or moving locally to a nearby suburb, your family may need to adjust to the amount of space in your new home. City homes, apartments, and condos often have less room for your seasonal items and other items you don’t use every day. When moving to a house in the suburbs, you may need temporary storage while you’re preparing to move or getting settled in. Renting self storage with Extra Space Storage while you move is a great option to free up some room while you unpack and move into your new space!
FAQs
Is it better to raise a family in the city or the suburbs?
Choosing to live in the suburbs or the city will depend entirely on the needs of your family. Cities offer convenient access to schools, public transportation, and urban amenities, while the suburbs offer larger homes and yards, as well as quieter neighborhoods.
Are suburbs really cheaper than cities for families?
The suburbs can often be a more budget-friendly option for families because cities tend to have higher housing costs per square foot—but final costs will ultimately depend on things like the area you’re moving to, transportation options, childcare expenses, and more.
Does living in the suburbs mean worse job opportunities?
Living in the suburbs doesn’t mean that you have worse job opportunities. Many suburban areas are home to major employers and business districts. Remote and hybrid jobs have also made where you live less important for some employees.
What’s the best option for families with remote-working parents?
The best options for parents who work at home will depend on a few factors, like childcare, the amount of space you need to do your job, and the proximity to your child’s school if they are enrolled.
***
Thinking of moving your family to a new city or suburb? Extra Space Storage has convenient storage facilities across the country to help your family transition smoothly. Find self storage near you!
