1 / 7

Extra Space Storage1414 Route 23Butler, NJ 07405

New Customer:
Current Customer: (973) 291-3352

Nearby Locations

1 / 7

4.9

Butler Self Storage at 1414 Route 23

1414 Route 23, Butler, NJ 07405

Current Customer: (973) 291-3352
New Customer:

Select a Unit Below

‌

Small

5' x 5'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$42

WEB RATE

$31

Small

5' x 5'

1st Floor Access
Climate Controlled
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$70

WEB RATE

$52

Small

5' x 10'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$67

WEB RATE

$50

5x10 storage units are a great solution for a wide range of short-term and long-term self storage needs, including moving to a new home, storing college dorm room items, using storage while deployed, and decluttering a house or apartment. These units are comparable in size to a walk-in closet. 5x10 units can typically hold the contents of a small bedroom or dorm room, such as a queen-size mattress set, dresser, TV, and several boxes.

Small

5' x 10'

1st Floor Access
Climate Controlled
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$121

WEB RATE

$91

Small

10' x 7'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$108

WEB RATE

$81

Medium

10' x 9'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

IN STORE

$116

WEB RATE

$87

Medium

10' x 10'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$124

WEB RATE

$93

Medium

10' x 10'

1st Floor Access
Climate Controlled
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$159

WEB RATE

$120

Medium

10' x 15'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$168

WEB RATE

$126

10x15 storage units are available as enclosed self storage units or as outdoor vehicle parking spaces. If you rent a 10x15 enclosed unit, you can store the contents of a small apartment or house, including furniture, appliances, and several moving boxes. If you rent a 10x15 outdoor parking space, you can store a motorcycle or small watercraft—though you’ll need to check with the facility on specific vehicle storage guidelines.

Medium

10' x 15'

1st Floor Access
Climate Controlled
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$226

WEB RATE

$169

Large

10' x 20'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$210

WEB RATE

$157

10x20 storage units are one of the largest unit sizes offered. Depending on the facility, these storage spaces may be available as enclosed units or as outdoor vehicle parking. Enclosed 10x20 units can hold the contents of a multi-bedroom home, including furniture, moving boxes, and appliances. Outdoor 10x20 parking spaces can typically accommodate RVs, boats, cars, and motorcycles—though you’ll need to check with the facility on specific vehicle storage guidelines.

Large

10' x 20'

Climate Controlled
Elevator Access
Indoor
Multi-Door Unit

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$210

WEB RATE

$157

Large

10' x 30'

1st Floor Access
Climate Controlled
Indoor

Size Help

Learn More

IN STORE

$398

WEB RATE

$338

10x30 storage units are among the largest unit sizes our storage locations, and they may be available as either enclosed units or as outdoor vehicle parking spaces. With 10x30 enclosed units, you can store the contents of a large multi-bedroom home. With 10x30 outdoor parking spots, you can store a vehicle, such as a motorcycle, car, boat, camper, or RV—though you’ll need to check with the facility on specific vehicle storage guidelines.

Units Available Nearby

5' x 2'

Available now at 51 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442 starting at $23/mo

Available Nearby

5' x 4'

Available now at 112 State Rt 23, Riverdale, NJ 07457 starting at $33/mo

Available Nearby

20' x 6'

Available now at 51 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442 starting at $113/mo

Available Nearby

Nearby Locations

Convenient Self Storage Near You in Butler

Located near the intersection of NJ-23 and Kiel Ave, Extra Space Storage in Butler proudly serves residents in the surrounding communities of Kinnelon, Apshawa, Pompton Lakes, and Riverdale. Locals will recognize our facility across from Quick Chek.

Available Storage Unit Sizes

From 5x5 to 10x25, our storage units offer a variety of unit sizes with indoor access, first-floor access, and elevator access for easy loading and unloading.

Drive-In Building

Extra Space Storage at 1414 Route 23 is a drive-in building, meaning you can pull your vehicle into the facility to unload or load your belongings. This storage amenity is especially helpful during New Jersey's cold seasons.

Climate-Controlled Storage

Need to store temperature-sensitive items? Climate control can help protect your belongings from extreme temperature changes. These units typically maintain a storage environment between 55 and 80 degrees throughout the year.

Exceptional Security Features

Extra Space Storage cares about your stored items. That's why our 1414 Route 23 storage facility utilizes high-quality security features like video surveillance and electronic gate access.

Other Amenities & Services

Sturdy moving carts available for heavy, bulky items
Convenient loading dock
Covered, heated loading bay
Elevators for easy access to upper levels
Accommodates trucks larger than 20 feet
Wide-drive aisles to accommodate large moving trucks
Gate access on Sundays
Deliveries accepted
On-site office

Cheap Self Storage in Butler

If you need an affordable self storage solution in Butler, Extra Space Storage on Route 23 has what you’re looking for! We offer cheap storage units with prices as low as $31 at this location. At select locations, you can also take advantage of great move-in deals like first month free and first month half-off when you reserve storage with us online!

The Self Storage Partner You Can Trust

Experience the convenience and value of Extra Space Storage. Our well-maintained facility offers a secure and reliable environment for your belongings, and our friendly staff is committed to making your storage experience as easy and stress free as possible. Contact us today to reserve a storage unit in Butler!

Company

Employees: 1-10

Payment Options: MasterCard / VISA / American Express / Discover / Check / Cash / Invoice

Established Date: 1977

Site Number: 6541

Phone Number:(973) 302-5794

Hours

Access

Monday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Office

Monday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday:9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Sunday:Closed

Directions

Intersections/Landmarks

Route 23 and Valley Rd

Directions from the North

Drive southeast on NJ-23 S. Take the Butler exit. Keep left for the Kiel Ave ramp. Turn left onto Kinnelon Rd. Continue driving southeast onto Kiel Ave. Turn right onto Western Ave. Turn right onto Valley Rd. Turn right onto NJ-23 N. Our facility will be on your right.

Directions from the South

Drive northwest on NJ-23 N. Pass Boonton Ave and continue driving northwest. Our facility will be on your right, after Valley Rd.

Directions from the East

Drive northwest on NJ-23 N. Pass Boonton Ave and continue driving northwest. Our facility will be on your right, after Valley Rd.

Directions from the West

Drive northeast on Kinnelon Rd. Pass NJ-23 and continue driving southeast onto Kiel Ave. Turn right onto Western Ave. Turn right onto Valley Rd. Turn right onto NJ-23 N. Our facility will be on your right.

Frequently Asked Questions at 1414 Route 23

Can I visit my storage unit after hours in Butler, NJ?

At Extra Space Storage at 1414 Route 23, we want customers to visit their storage unit when it's most convenient. Check with the facility manager today about our specific access hours to see if extended access hours or 24/7 access are available!

Do I need insurance to store my vehicle in Extra Space Storage at 1414 Route 23?

Yes! Every customer renting vehicle storage in Butler must provide proof of insurance for their vehicle before storing it with Extra Space Storage.

How much will a 5x5 storage unit hold in Butler?

To learn more about what Extra Space Storage unit sizes can hold, check out our handy storage unit size guide! You can also call our 1414 Route 23 storage facility to get recommendations from our friendly, professional self storage experts.

What type of lock do I need for a storage unit?

At Extra Space Storage, we require all customers at our 1414 Route 23 location to have a secure lock for their storage unit. You can even purchase locks at our storage facility. Contact us today to learn more about which locks we require for our storage units!

Why is it important to rent a temperature-controlled storage unit in Butler, NJ?

Depending on what you plan to store at Extra Space Storage in Butler, choosing a climate-controlled unit adds one more layer of protection for your sensitive items. These units typically maintain temperatures between 55 and 80 degrees throughout the year, which is good when storing sensitive items like business documents, electronics, artwork, and more.

*Promotional Terms & Conditions and Size Disclaimer

Promotional Terms

Limit, one promotion per customer. Promotions cannot be used in conjunction with any other offer except for web rate pricing. Promotions are subject to change and availability. Promotions may not be available in-store. Promotions do not apply to taxes, insurance, administrative fees, or other fees. Promotions must be applied at time of checkout and cannot be applied to an existing rental, once rented. See Rental Agreement for additional details.

Half-Off and Free Rent Promotions

Only available at participating locations for selected units. “First Month Free,” “First Month Half Off,” “Second Month Free,” “Second Month Half Off” and other rent promotions do not apply to taxes, insurance, administrative fees, or other fees and may not be combined.

$50 Moving Truck Credit in New York City

Only available at participating locations for selected units. Extra Space will provide a $50.00 credit for customers that use a moving truck or moving service to move into the Extra Space facility. To redeem, customers must provide a valid receipt from the moving service to the store manager. Please see the store manager for additional details.

Size Disclaimer

Unit sizes advertised for rent are approximate only and units at the self-storage facility may differ slightly in shape and/or size. Customers should inspect the actual unit to be rented before signing a rental agreement and should base the decision to rent on the inspection of the unit and not on the advertised unit size. Rental amounts for a particular unit are not based on square footage measurements.

Reviews

4.8 stars

107 Reviews

5 stars101

4 stars2

3 stars0

2 stars0

1 star4

Showing 3 of 107

Dave

June 27, 2026

Such a clean facility, joe at the front desk is a wonderful and helpful guy! Will always come back for storage when I need it!

We're delighted to hear about your positive experience at Extra Space Storage, Dave. Thank you for your kind words about our facility and Joe's helpfulness.

Extra Space Storage (6/27/2026)

Google Review

Terry

June 22, 2026

Joe is the best customer service person ever . He is kind , helpful and knowledgeable. Every customer service representative should be like him!

Thanks, Terry! Joe's kindness and knowledge clearly made a difference. We're proud to have him on our team!

Extra Space Storage (6/22/2026)

Google Review

Chris

June 2, 2026

Awesome customer service, joe was fantastic, fast and speedy help

Thank you for sharing your feedback, Chris! We're delighted Joe provided fantastic, speedy service. Your experience means everything to us.

Extra Space Storage (6/2/2026)

Google Review

Butler Self Storage at 1414 Route 23

Select a Unit Below

Units Available Nearby

Convenient Self Storage Near You in Butler

Available Storage Unit Sizes

Drive-In Building

Climate-Controlled Storage

Exceptional Security Features

Other Amenities & Services

Cheap Self Storage in Butler

The Self Storage Partner You Can Trust

Hours

Access

Office

Directions

Frequently Asked Questions at 1414 Route 23

Can I visit my storage unit after hours in Butler, NJ?

Do I need insurance to store my vehicle in Extra Space Storage at 1414 Route 23?

How much will a 5x5 storage unit hold in Butler?

What type of lock do I need for a storage unit?

Why is it important to rent a temperature-controlled storage unit in Butler, NJ?

Reviews

4.8 stars

Dave

Terry

Chris

Company Information

More Information

Help

Self Storage Locations

Recently Searched Locations

Today's Hours

Butler Self Storage at 1414 Route 23

Today's Hours

Select a Unit Below

Units Available Nearby

Convenient Self Storage Near You in Butler

Available Storage Unit Sizes

Drive-In Building

Climate-Controlled Storage

Exceptional Security Features

Other Amenities & Services

Cheap Self Storage in Butler

The Self Storage Partner You Can Trust

Hours

Access

Office

Directions

Frequently Asked Questions at 1414 Route 23

Can I visit my storage unit after hours in Butler, NJ?

Do I need insurance to store my vehicle in Extra Space Storage at 1414 Route 23?

How much will a 5x5 storage unit hold in Butler?

What type of lock do I need for a storage unit?

Why is it important to rent a temperature-controlled storage unit in Butler, NJ?

Reviews

4.8 stars

Dave

Terry

Chris

Company Information

More Information

Help

Self Storage Locations

Recently Searched Locations