Today's Hours

Access:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Office:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
24/7 access available when you upgrade
Nearby Locations
4.7

Allegany Self Storage at 3864 Route 417

Today's Hours

Access:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Office:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
24/7 access available when you upgrade
Select a Unit Below
Medium
12' x 10'
  • Drive-Up Access
IN STORE
$169
WEB RATE
$115

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Medium
10' x 15'
  • Drive-Up Access
IN STORE
$196
WEB RATE
$134

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Large
10' x 20'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$218
WEB RATE
$148

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Large
12' x 25'
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
IN STORE
$288
WEB RATE
$199

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Large
12' x 25'
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
IN STORE
$288
WEB RATE
$199

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Large
14' x 47'
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Heated
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
IN STORE
$475
WEB RATE
$372

LIMITED UNITS

Large
14' x 47'
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Heated
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
IN STORE
$475
WEB RATE
$372

LIMITED UNITS

Units Available Nearby

5' x 5'

Available now at 6010 Big Tree Rd, Orchard Park, NY 14127 starting at $37/mo

Available Nearby

10' x 9'

Available now at 4462 Southwestern Blvd, Hamburg, NY 14075 starting at $87/mo

Available Nearby

10' x 10'

Available now at 6010 Big Tree Rd, Orchard Park, NY 14127 starting at $84/mo

Available Nearby

Nearby Locations

Self Storage You Can Trust in Allegany

Looking for storage while moving, expanding your business, or going through a significant life transition? Find everything you need with Extra Space Storage! Our Allegany storage facility is clean and secured with a perimeter fence, gated access, and surveillance cameras to help protect your valuables. Plus, we have a reliable customer service team that's happy to answer any questions you may have!

Find Us Near Route 417 & W 1st St

Located near the intersection of Route 417 and W 1st St, Extra Space Storage at 3864 Route 417 is easily accessible for residents of Allegany, St Bonaventure, Weston Mills, Carrollton, Limestone, Olean, and more. You'll recognize us east of The New Lantern Motel and Colonial Village.

Storage Amenities Available in Allegany

Extra Space Storage in Allegany has a variety of solutions available to both residential and commercial storage customers! Learn more about our storage unit options below.

Unit Sizes

We offer a wide variety of storage units in Allegany, with sizes ranging from as small as 5x5 to as large as 14x42. We also have convenient unit features like indoor access, ground-level access, and drive-up access to help make the storage process even easier!

Drive-Up Access

Planning to store large, heavy items? Our drive-up access units in Allegany are the perfect choice for you! These units allow you to drive your vehicle right up next to your storage unit's door so you can load and unload your items more efficiently.

Climate Control & Heated Units

Need to store temperature-sensitive items? Climate control can help protect your belongings from extreme temperature changes. These units typically maintain a storage environment between 55 and 80 degrees throughout the year.

Vehicle Storage

If you're looking for secure vehicle storage in Allegany, check out the many options available to you at Extra Space Storage! Our drive-up storage units are perfect for cars and motorcycles, while larger vehicles like boats, RVs, and campers fit well in our covered and uncovered outdoor parking spaces.

Business Storage

Store your office supplies, work equipment, and other company essentials at Extra Space Storage! As your trustworthy partner for commercial storage in Allegany, our facility has a wide array of unit sizes, features, and amenities, so you can store with ease and confidence. Ask us about our workshop units!

Other Facility Features

  • Extended access hours are standard - ask site manager for details

  • Cylinder locks required for units

  • Sturdy moving carts available for heavy, bulky items

  • Covered loading bay

  • Accommodates trucks larger than 20 feet

  • Wide-drive aisles to accommodate large moving trucks

  • Gate access on Sundays

  • Convenient freeway access

  • Deliveries accepted

  • On-site office

Cheap Storage Units in Allegany

Looking for affordable self storage in Allegany? Extra Space Storage has the solutions you need. We offer cheap self storage near you for as low as $134 per month, with move-in deals like first month free and first month half-off at select facilities. Contact our expert team at 3864 Route 417 for current move-in deals and rent your unit today!

Company

Employees: 1-10

Payment Options: MasterCard / VISA / American Express / Discover / Check / Cash / Invoice

Established Date: 1977

Site Number: 4243

Phone Number:(716) 219-7000

Hours

Access

  • Monday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Office

  • Monday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Tuesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Wednesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Thursday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Friday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Saturday:9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Sunday:Closed

Directions

Intersections/Landmarks

W 5 Mile Rd and Route 417

Directions from the North

Drive south on W 5 Mile Rd. Turn left onto Route 417 E toward Allegany. Our facility will be immediately on your left.

Directions from the South

Drive north on 4 Mile Rd. Continue straight onto 1st St and keep driving north. Turn left onto W Main St. Our facility will be on your right.

Directions from the East

Drive west on Route 417 W. Pass Constitution Ave and continue driving northwest. Our facility will be on your right after Sheldon Dr.

Directions from the West

Drive east on I-86 E. Take Exit 24. Turn right onto W 5 Mile Rd. Turn left onto Route 417 E toward Allegany. Our facility will be immediately on your left.

Frequently Asked Questions at 3864 Route 417

What size storage space do I need for an RV or camper?

Smaller RVs can fit into 10x26 outdoor parking spaces, while larger RVs may need a 10x30 space. Ask a facility manager if indoor RV parking is available now. Or check out more RV storage tips and options on our RV storage guide.

When can I get into my storage unit after booking?

Use our Rent Now button to purchase your unit in minutes. Once you receive your personalized access code, you can enter the facility during gate hours.

How many moving boxes should I buy for my two-bedroom home?

For a two-bedroom home, try using 10 small boxes, 6 medium boxes, and 3 large boxes. Find more detailed packing lists and ship moving supplies to your home with our moving boxes and supplies guide.

Does Extra Space Storage give military discounts to active service members?

Military discounts may be available at select locations throughout the year. Ask your facility manager to see what discounts are available for active duty and veterans.

What's the deadline for paying my storage unit bill each month?

Rental payments are due once a month on the date defined in your rental contract. It's likely the same day your rental agreement began at your Extra Space Storage facility. For payment reminders or business invoices, go to My Account.

What is the relationship between Life Storage and Extra Space Storage?

Extra Space Storage bought Life Storage in 2023 making Life Storage part of the Extra Space Storage family. Combined, Extra Space Storage and Life Storage make up nearly 4,000 self storage locations across the United States.

*Promotional Terms & Conditions and Size Disclaimer

Reviews

May 2, 2026

James

Posted On Google

overall rating

Great customer service

Response from Extra Space Storage (5/3/2026)

We are ecstatic to hear about your positive experience with our customer service team, James!

May 1, 2026

Michael

Posted On Google

overall rating

Online rental, easy. Very clean

Response from Extra Space Storage (5/1/2026)

We are pleased to hear you found our online rental process easy and appreciated the cleanliness, Michael!

April 29, 2026

VIctor

Posted On Google

overall rating

Good stuff

Response from Extra Space Storage (4/29/2026)

We are pleased to hear you had a positive experience with Extra Space Storage, Victor!

April 29, 2026

Tim

Posted On Google

overall rating

Joshua and Tyler are incredible employees, they are so friendly and eager to help in any way possible. I will never go anywhere else

Response from Extra Space Storage (4/29/2026)

Thank you for sharing your kind words about Joshua and Tyler! We're thrilled they provided such friendly, helpful service, Tim.

April 29, 2026

JetFan

Posted On Google

overall rating

A+

Response from Extra Space Storage (4/29/2026)

Hi, Jetfan, Thank you for the 5-star review. We're so happy you had a great experience with Extra Space Storage.

*savings reflected in rates.