Storage Units in Allegany, NY: Find Cheap Self Storage Near You

Extra Space Storage provides self storage in Allegany near Weston Mills, St Bonaventure, Limestone, Olean, Carrollton, and other surrounding areas. Fi...
Extra Space Storage provides self storage in Allegany near Weston Mills, St Bonaventure, Limestone, Olean, Carrollton, and other surrounding areas. Find the storage solutions you need at one of our secure facilities today, with everything from climate-controlled storage to drive-up access units!

1 location near allegany Found

‌
Extra Space Storage facility at 3864 Route 417 - Allegany, NY
4.7
1.5 mi
3864 Route 417
Allegany, NY 14706
    No Units Available

    See available units & prices at this facility

    View

    Prices exclude administration and insurance fees.

    Prices exclude administration and insurance fees.

    Why Extra Space Storage?

    When you rent with Extra Space Storage, you'll benefit from affordable rental prices, convenient amenities, and reliable security measures. Plus, our friendly staff members are here to help you find the best storage solutions for your needs and answer any questions you may have!

    Allegany Self Storage Features & Amenities

    Storage units in Allegany come in sizes ranging from 25 square feet to 300+ square feet to satisfy a variety of self storage needs. You'll also find units equipped with useful features like ground-level access, indoor access, and drive-up access for your convenience!

    Rapid Rental

    Ready to rent your storage unit from Extra Space Storage? Complete the rental process within a matter of minutes! Just select your unit, fill out the required paperwork, and submit your payment details. You'll receive a code to access your storage unit so you can move in at your convenience!

    Climate Controlled

    If you plan to store delicate belongings, we highly recommend renting a self storage unit with climate control. This amenity typically keeps your unit between 55 and 80 degrees year-round, which can help protect your items from extreme temperature changes.

    Drive-Up Access

    Drive-up access allows you to park your vehicle right next to your unit for a simpler loading and unloading process. Rather than carrying heavy, bulky items across long distances, you can store them quickly by opting for drive-up storage in Allegany!

    Vehicle Storage

    Your search for dependable vehicle storage options in Allegany is over! Browse our selection of indoor units with drive-up access for small vehicles like cars and motorcycles. Or park your campers, RVs, boats, and other large vehicles in one of our spacious covered or uncovered outdoor parking spots.

    Business Storage

    If you need affordable commercial storage solutions in Allegany, you can count on Extra Space Storage! Store anything from office files to large pieces of equipment by taking advantage of our numerous storage unit sizes, amenities, and features.

    Exceptional Security

    At Extra Space Storage in Allegany, we utilize advanced security features like surveillance cameras, perimeter fencing, and gated access. We care about the valued belongings of our customers.

    Extended Access Hours

    We understand that our customers have busy schedules and can't always stop by during traditional business hours. That's why we offer extended access hours from 6am to 10pm, so you can access your Allegany storage unit at the times that are most convenient for you!

    Customer Reviews Near Allegany, New York

    4.7

    Renters rated Extra Space Storage’s service and storage units in Allegany 4.7 out of 5, based on 169 Google reviews.

    Unit Size Comparisons

    See exactly how unit sizes compare on price, space, and value — side by side.

    5' x 5'

    5' x 10'

    Avg. Monthly Price$35.00
    Avg. Monthly Price$53.00+$18/mo
    Square Footage25 sq ft
    Square Footage50 sq ft+100% more
    Cost per Sq Ft$1.40
    Cost per Sq Ft$1.06-$0.34/sq ft
    Value Insight: While a 5x10 unit costs 51% more per month, you get 100% more space than a 5x5—making it 24% more cost-efficient per square foot for Allegany renters.

    5' x 10'

    10' x 10'

    Avg. Monthly Price$53.00
    Avg. Monthly Price$94.00+$41/mo
    Square Footage50 sq ft
    Square Footage100 sq ft+100% more
    Cost per Sq Ft$1.06
    Cost per Sq Ft$0.94-$0.12/sq ft
    Value Insight: If you're clearing out a living room or 1-bedroom apartment in Allegany, a 10x10 storage may be the right choice—and costs 77% more than a 5x10. You’ll get 11% more value per square foot when upgrading to a 10x10.

    10' x 15'

    10' x 20'

    Avg. Monthly Price$135.00
    Avg. Monthly Price$149.00+$14/mo
    Square Footage150 sq ft
    Square Footage200 sq ft+33% more
    Cost per Sq Ft$0.90
    Cost per Sq Ft$0.75-$0.15/sq ft
    Value Insight: Renting a 10x20 storage unit in Allegany gets you 33% more space than a 10x15—enough for a 3–4 bedroom home. At 10% more per month, you’re getting 17% more value per square foot.

    Storage available near Allegany, NY

    Need additional information?

    SIZE GUIDE
    CLIMATE CONTROLLED STORAGE
    VEHICLE STORAGE
    RV STORAGE
    BUSINESS STORAGE
    DRIVE-UP ACCESS
    24/7 ACCESS
    MOVING SUPPLIES

    Storage Unit Information

    Small Storage Units

    • 1 storage facilities near Allegany, NY have small sized 5' x 10' storage units available now, starting at $53 and averaging $53 per month.

    Medium Storage Units

    • 1 self storage facilities near Allegany, NY have medium sized 10' x 10' units available starting at $94, with an average price of $94 per month.

    • 1 storage facilities near Allegany, NY have medium 10' x 15' units available now, starting at $124 and averaging $135 per month.

    Large Storage Units

    • 1 self storage facilities near Allegany, NY have large 10' x 20' storage units available, starting at $149 and averaging $149 per month.

    Climate Controlled & RV/Boat Storage Units

    • 1 self storage facilities near Allegany, NY have Climate Controlled storage units available starting at $53, with an average price of $105 per month.

    NEED HELP FINDING THE RIGHT SIZE?

    We offer a Right-Size Guarantee: you can change your selected size at the facility to best meet your storage needs.

    SIZE GUIDE

    Frequently Asked Questions in Allegany, NY

    How much do storage units in Allegany, NY cost?

    You can expect one of our most popular sizes, like a 5x5 storage unit, to start as low as $35 and average $35 per month in Allegany, NY. Depending on the exact amenities and facility you choose, the exact cost may vary.

    Should I get a climate-controlled storage unit in Allegany, NY?

    If you’re planning to store items sensitive to extreme heat or cold, like wood, books, newspaper, artwork, or collectibles, we recommend renting a climate-controlled storage unit in Allegany. These units typically maintain an interior temperature between 55 and 80 degrees, which can help protect your belongings year-round.

    What sizes of units are offerred within Allegany?

    Our storage units in Allegany are available in various sizes, with standard units ranging from 5x5 to 10x20.

    Can I use a storage unit for commercial or business use?

    The average height of our storage units is 8 ft tall, giving you plenty of vertical space to organize and distribute your belongings.

    *savings reflected in rates.

    Company Information

    More Information

    Help

    Self Storage Locations

    Recently Searched Locations

    Need Help?

    Learn More About Extra Space Storage

    Extra Space Storage Inc., headquartered in Salt Lake City, Utah, owns and/or operates over 4,200 self storage properties in 42 states, and Washington, D.C. The Company's stores comprise approximately 2.5 million storage units and over 280 million square feet of rentable space, offering customers a wide selection of affordable and conveniently located and secure storage solutions across the country, including personal storage, boat storage, RV storage and business storage. We are committed to being the most convenient, secure, and professional storage solution in your neighborhood. And it is this commitment which has enabled Extra Space Storage to become the largest storage units operator in the U.S. with over 4,200 properties across the country.

    © 2006 - 2026 Extra Space Storage Inc.

    Privacy Policy

    Manage Preferences
    Click to verify BBB accreditation and to see a BBB report.