Extra Space Storage at 1775 5th Ave

4.8
    Call our Storage Experts
    Storage Experts Available
    Mon-Fri: 06:00am-01:00am
    Sat: 06:00am-01:00am
    Sun: 06:00am-01:00am
  • New Customer: 
  • Current Customer: (631) 350-9350

Today's Hours

Access:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Office:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
24/7 Access
With upgrade
4.8

Extra Space Storage at 1775 5th Ave

Call our Storage Experts
Storage Experts Available
Mon-Fri: 06:00am-01:00am
Sat: 06:00am-01:00am
Sun: 06:00am-01:00am

Today's Hours

Access:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Office:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
24/7 Access
With upgrade
Select a Unit Below
‌
‌

Locker

Great for boxes, seasonal decor, and personal items

No locker units are currently available at this location.Find locker Units Nearby

Small Storage

Ideal for studios and 1-bedroom apartments

Small
5' x 5'
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$63
WEB RATE
$39

LIMITED UNITS

Small
5' x 5'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$75
WEB RATE
$50

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Small
5' x 8'
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$88
WEB RATE
$55
Small
5' x 10'
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$105
WEB RATE
$65
Small
5' x 10'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$122
WEB RATE
$82

LIMITED UNITS

Small
7' x 10'
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$133
WEB RATE
$83

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Small
8' x 10'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$170
WEB RATE
$114

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Medium Storage

Ideal for 1-2 bedroom apartments, condos, and small homes

Medium
10' x 10'
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$175
WEB RATE
$114
Medium
10' x 10'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$202
WEB RATE
$128

LIMITED UNITS

Medium
10' x 15'
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$237
WEB RATE
$155

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Medium
10' x 15'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$270
WEB RATE
$172
Medium
8' x 20'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$282
WEB RATE
$180

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Large Storage

Ideal for 3+ bedroom homes, full furniture sets, and large appliances

Large
10' x 20'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$347
WEB RATE
$237

LIMITED UNITS

Large
10' x 30'
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
IN STORE
$464
WEB RATE
$343

ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!

Vehicle Storage

Great for cars, boats, RVs, and other vehicles

Parking
10' x 20'
  • Outdoor Parking
  • RV Parking
IN STORE
$176
WEB RATE
$115

LIMITED UNITS

Units Available Nearby

2' x 2'

Available now at 110 Saxon Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 starting at $13/mo

Available Nearby

10' x 3'

Available now at 225 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 starting at $60/mo

Available Nearby

8' x 17'

Available now at 200 Express Dr S, Brentwood, NY 11717 starting at $84/mo

Available Nearby

Nearby Locations

EXPLORE NEARBY LOCATIONS

Convenient Self Storage Near You in Bay Shore

Located near the intersection of Candlewood Rd and 5th Ave, Extra Space Storage at 1775 5th Ave can be found within 1 mile of Pine Aire and within 5 miles of Central Islip and Brightwaters. Locals will recognize our facility near CVS.

Available Storage Unit Sizes

Our Bay Shore self storage facility offers everything from small 3x5 storage lockers to large 10x25 standard units. We also have units with features like indoor access, first-floor access, and elevator access.

Climate-Controlled Storage

Need to store temperature-sensitive items? Climate control can help protect your belongings from extreme temperature changes. These units typically maintain a storage environment between 55 and 80 degrees throughout the year.

Outdoor Vehicle Storage

Looking for secure vehicle storage in Bay Shore? Our 5th Ave self storage facility has uncovered outdoor parking spaces that are perfect for storing large vehicles like boats, RVs, trailers, and campers.

Exceptional Security Features

Extra Space Storage in Bay Shore is equipped with advanced security features like video surveillance and security access to your floor only to help protect your belongings and provide a safe storage environment.

Other Amenities & Services

  • Extended access hours are standard with 24/7 access available - ask site manager for details

  • Sturdy moving carts available for heavy, bulky items

  • Convenient loading dock

  • Elevators for easy access to upper levels

  • Accommodates trucks larger than 20 feet

  • Wide-drive aisles to accommodate large moving trucks

  • Se Habla Espanol

  • Convenient freeway access

  • On-site office

  • Deliveries accepted

Cheap Bay Shore Self Storage

With cheap storage unit prices as low as $50 in Bay Shore plus great move-in deals like first month free or first month half-off at select facilities, Extra Space Storage is the affordable self storage partner near you. Reserve high-quality self storage at 1775 5th Ave today!

The Self Storage Partner You Can Trust

At Extra Space Storage, we're committed to excellent customer service. Our friendly, professional staff works hard to keep our facility clean at all times, and they're more than happy to answer any questions you may have. Contact us today to reserve a storage unit in Bay Shore!

Company

Employees: 1-10

Payment Options: MasterCard / VISA / American Express / Discover / Check / Cash / Invoice

Established Date: 1977

Site Number: 7569

Phone Number:(631) 210-6603

Hours

Access

  • Monday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Saturday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sunday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Office

  • Monday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Tuesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Wednesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Thursday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Friday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
  • Saturday:9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
  • Sunday:Closed

Directions

Intersections/Landmarks

Candlewood Rd and 5th Ave

Directions from the North

Drive south on Wicks Rd. Continue onto 5th Ave. Our facility will be on your left after Fairtown Rd.

Directions from the South

Drive north on 5th Ave. Pass Spur Dr N and continue north. Our facility will be on your right after Candlewood Rd.

Directions from the East

Drive west on Suffolk Ave. Turn left onto 5th Ave. Our facility will be on your left after Fairtown Rd.

Directions from the West

Drive east on Long Island Ave. Turn right onto Grant Ave. Turn left onto Pine Aire Dr. Turn right onto 5th Ave. Our facility will be on your left.

Frequently Asked Questions at 1775 5th Ave

Does 1775 5th Ave have 24 hour access self storage?

Access hours vary by location. Some locations offer extended access hours, while others may have 24/7 access available. Contact Extra Space Storage at 1775 5th Ave to learn more about our storage facility access hours!

How secure are storage units at 1775 5th Ave?

Our Bay Shore storage facilities are backed by advanced security features, such as video surveillance, security access to your floor only, individually-alarmed storage units, and electronic gate access!

What size padlock should I use for storage unit at 1775 5th Ave?

Storage units at our 1775 5th Ave storage facility have no set lock size required. If you're not sure the lock you have is secure enough, Extra Space Storage sells secure disc locks along with other helpful moving supplies!

Where can I buy moving boxes at 1775 5th Ave?

Extra Space Storage proudly offers a wide selection of moving boxes for purchase at our 1775 5th Ave storage facility! From small bankers boxes to larger wardrobe boxes, we have the supplies you need to make your move as smooth as possible in Bay Shore.

Can I work out of storage units at 1775 5th Ave?

You may not be able to work directly out of a storage unit at our 1775 5th Ave storage facility, but Extra Space Storage does allow business storage customers to utilize their storage units for storing inventory, equipment, materials, documents, and other business items. Contact us today to learn more!

*Promotional Terms & Conditions and Size Disclaimer

Reviews

4.8 stars

505 Reviews
5 stars465
4 stars16
3 stars3
2 stars6
1 star15
Showing 3 of 505

Lil_jonny

November 16, 2026

Great energy, funny, kind come speak to him to get right.

Thank you for the kind words! We're glad our team member made such a great impression at Extra Space Storage!

Extra Space Storage (11/16/2026)

Google IconGoogle Review

Gino

November 10, 2026

Great service! Everything is super fast, and the place is super clean and well-maintained. The customer service is great and the staff is very friendly, especially Siabhon. 100% recommended.

Thank you, Gino, for sharing your experience and for the recommendation. We are glad to hear that you received fast service and found our facility clean and well-maintained. We will share your kind words with Siabhon and the rest of the team at Extra Space Storage!

Extra Space Storage (11/10/2026)

Google IconGoogle Review

Reaper

November 7, 2026

Faith at the Bay Shore location is absolutely amazing. THE MAIN reason I have been a tenant here for so long is due to her kindness, respect and professionalism. ALWAYS helpful in answering all my questions and going out of her way to make sure I am happy with my units.

Your positive feedback means a great deal to us. We’re delighted that Faith’s kindness, respect, and professionalism have made your experience at our Bay Shore location so positive.

Extra Space Storage (11/2/2026)

Google IconGoogle Review

*savings reflected in rates.