Self Storage in Bay Shore, NY: Find Storage Units Near You!

Need help finding the RIGHT SIZE?

Try our size guide
Click to verify BBB accreditation and to see a BBB report.
View all Locations in new york

View Facilities Near You new york

Open Map
Select your
SIZE & LOCATION BELOW
How much space do you need?
Click Here to Find Out
Select a Facility Below
Sort by

    Find affordable, secure self storage in Bay Shore with Extra Space Storage! We have convenient storage locations near Brentwood, North Bay Shore, Pine Aire, Islip, and more!

    5' x 5' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $55

    In-Store

    $43

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $178

    In-Store

    $137

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 20' Large

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Climate Controlled
    • Indoor

    $351

    In-Store

    $285

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    5' x 5' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $95

    In-Store

    $71

    Web Rate

    First Month Free*

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $211

    In-Store

    $158

    Web Rate

    First Month Free*

    10' x 20' Large

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Climate Controlled
    • Indoor

    $457

    In-Store

    $397

    Web Rate

    First Month Free*

    3

    1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Islandia, New York, 11749

    View Map

    Read 220 Reviews

    "Great experience!"Read More

    4' x 10' Small

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $91

    In-Store

    $56

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    6' x 16' Medium

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $215

    In-Store

    $162

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 19' Large

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $322

    In-Store

    $242

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    4

    3016 Express Dr S, Islandia, New York, 11749

    View Map

    Read 166 Reviews

    "Great prices friendly staff ,sills rd"Read More

    5' x 5' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $91

    In-Store

    $71

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $206

    In-Store

    $159

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 20' Large

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Climate Controlled
    • Indoor

    $432

    In-Store

    $352

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    5' x 5' Small

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor

    $84

    In-Store

    $68

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 10' Medium

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor

    $220

    In-Store

    $167

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 20' Large

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor

    $378

    In-Store

    $300

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    6

    510 Johnson Ave, Bohemia, New York, 11716

    View Map

    Read 141 Reviews

    "Tony was a pleasure to work with very personable and informative"Read More

    5' x 5' Small

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $95

    In-Store

    $59

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $244

    In-Store

    $164

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 30' Large

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Enclosed Vehicle Storage

    $534

    In-Store

    $454

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    5' x 10' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Indoor
    • Stair Access

    $116

    In-Store

    $87

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 10' Medium

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor
    • Multidoor

    $212

    In-Store

    $159

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 20' Large

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Enclosed Vehicle Storage

    $341

    In-Store

    $281

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    8

    200 Express Dr S, Brentwood, New York, 11717

    View Map

    Read 211 Reviews

    "The best! Peter's great!"Read More

    5' x 5' Small

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Climate Controlled
    • Indoor

    $91

    In-Store

    $62

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $202

    In-Store

    $157

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    5' x 10' Small

    • Elevator Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor

    $134

    In-Store

    $110

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Elevator Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor

    $191

    In-Store

    $136

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 20' Large

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $440

    In-Store

    $360

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    5' x 5' Small

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Indoor

    $80

    In-Store

    $64

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $204

    In-Store

    $156

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 20' Large

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Enclosed Vehicle Storage

    $353

    In-Store

    $280

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    11

    2626 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, New York, 11720

    View Map

    Read 111 Reviews

    "Thank you John for your help!"Read More

    5' x 5' Small

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $90

    In-Store

    $65

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage

    $246

    In-Store

    $166

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 20' Large

    • Drive-Up Access
    • Enclosed Storage
    • Enclosed Vehicle Storage

    $375

    In-Store

    $295

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    5' x 5' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $110

    In-Store

    $88

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $265

    In-Store

    $185

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 20' Large

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $550

    In-Store

    $470

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    13

    380 Oakwood Rd, Huntington Station, New York, 11746

    View Map

    Read 165 Reviews

    "Debra is the best"Read More

    5' x 5' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $96

    In-Store

    $62

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 11' Medium

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Heated
    • Indoor

    $307

    In-Store

    $260

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    5' x 5' Small

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Heated
    • Indoor

    $83

    In-Store

    $53

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    10' x 10' Medium

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Heated
    • Indoor

    $220

    In-Store

    $141

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 20' Large

    • 1st Floor Access
    • Heated
    • Indoor

    $429

    In-Store

    $349

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS

    15

    789 S Broadway, Hicksville, New York, 11801

    View Map

    Read 398 Reviews

    "Great customer service...very good price as well."Read More

    5' x 5' Small

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $109

    In-Store

    $73

    Web Rate

    $50 Moving Truck Credit*

    10' x 10' Medium

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $211

    In-Store

    $135

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    10' x 20' Large

    • Climate Controlled
    • Elevator Access
    • Indoor

    $382

    In-Store

    $302

    Web Rate

    ACT FAST: 1 UNIT LEFT!

    +SEE MORE FACILITIES

    Frequently Asked Questions iin Bay Shore, New York

    Where can I buy moving boxes in Bay Shore, New York?

    Where can I store my RV when not in use in Bay Shore, New York?

    What is the average height of a storage unit in Bay Shore, New York?

    How much will a 10x10 storage unit hold in Bay Shore, New York?

    Can I rent a storage unit for 1 month in Bay Shore, New York?

    Why Choose Extra Space Storage

    Extra Space Storage strives to provide secure, well-maintained self storage for our customers. Our Bay Shore storage facilities utilize state-of-the-art security measures like video surveillance, electronic gate access, and security access to your floor only. But we don't stop there! We also have an amazing customer service available to provide assistance whenever you need help. Don't hesitate to reach out!

    Available Storage Units in Bay Shore

    Bay Shore storage units range in size from 25 square feet to 300+ square feet, so we can accommodate both residential and commercial self storage needs. Not sure what unit size is right for you? Our team can help!

    Climate-Controlled Storage in Bay Shore

    If you plan to store delicate belongings, we highly recommend renting a self storage unit with climate control. This amenity typically keeps your unit between 55 and 80 degrees year-round, which can help protect your items from extreme temperature changes.

    Secure Vehicle Storage in Bay Shore

    Extra Space Storage offers outdoor vehicle storage that can handle RV storage, boat storage, camper storage, car storage, and more. Contact us for more information!

    Affordable Prices & Great Move-In Deals

    We offer competitive pricing on our storage units, as well as move-in deals like first-month half-off and first month free. Take advantage by reserving a unit with Extra Space Storage now!

    Reserve Bay Shore Self Storage Today!

    Ready to secure your storage unit? You can reserve online or by phone with Extra Space Storage today with no credit card required! Have questions? Give our team a call!

    *Excludes administrative and insurance fees