Today's Hours
Bay Shore Self Storage at 1775 5th Ave
- Current Customer: (631) 350-9350
- New Customer:
Today's Hours
Select a Unit Below
- Climate Controlled
- Elevator Access
- Indoor
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- Climate Controlled
- Elevator Access
- Indoor
LIMITED UNITS
- Climate Controlled
- Elevator Access
- Indoor
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
- Climate Controlled
- Elevator Access
- Indoor
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
LIMITED UNITS
- Climate Controlled
- Elevator Access
- Indoor
LIMITED UNITS
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
LIMITED UNITS
- Climate Controlled
- Elevator Access
- Indoor
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
LIMITED UNITS
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- Outdoor Parking
- RV Parking
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
- Multi-Door Unit
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
ACT FAST: 1 LEFT!
- 1st Floor Access
- Climate Controlled
- Indoor
- Multi-Door Unit
LIMITED UNITS
Units Available Nearby
Available now at 110 Saxon Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 starting at $18/mo
Available now at 225 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 starting at $49/mo
Available now at 200 Express Dr S, Brentwood, NY 11717 starting at $115/mo
Convenient Self Storage Near You in Bay Shore
Located near the intersection of Candlewood Rd and 5th Ave, Extra Space Storage at 1775 5th Ave can be found within 1 mile of Pine Aire and within 5 miles of Central Islip and Brightwaters. Locals will recognize our facility near CVS.
Available Storage Unit Sizes
Our Bay Shore self storage facility offers everything from small 3x5 storage lockers to large 10x25 standard units. We also have units with features like indoor access, first-floor access, and elevator access.
Climate-Controlled Storage
Need to store temperature-sensitive items? Climate control can help protect your belongings from extreme temperature changes. These units typically maintain a storage environment between 55 and 80 degrees throughout the year.
Outdoor Vehicle Storage
Looking for secure vehicle storage in Bay Shore? Our 5th Ave self storage facility has uncovered outdoor parking spaces that are perfect for storing large vehicles like boats, RVs, trailers, and campers.
Exceptional Security Features
Extra Space Storage in Bay Shore is equipped with advanced security features like video surveillance and security access to your floor only to help protect your belongings and provide a safe storage environment.
Other Amenities & Services
Cylinder locks required for units
Sturdy moving carts available for heavy, bulky items
Convenient loading dock
Elevators for easy access to upper levels
Accommodates trucks larger than 20 feet
Wide-drive aisles to accommodate large moving trucks
Se Habla Espanol
Gate access on Sundays
Convenient freeway access
On-site office
Deliveries accepted
Cheap Bay Shore Self Storage
With cheap storage unit prices as low as $57 in Bay Shore plus great move-in deals like first month free or first month half-off at select facilities, Extra Space Storage is the affordable self storage partner near you. Reserve high-quality self storage at 1775 5th Ave today!
The Self Storage Partner You Can Trust
At Extra Space Storage, we're committed to excellent customer service. Our friendly, professional staff works hard to keep our facility clean at all times, and they're more than happy to answer any questions you may have. Contact us today to reserve a storage unit in Bay Shore!
Company
Employees: 1-10
Payment Options: MasterCard / VISA / American Express / Discover / Check / Cash / Invoice
Established Date: 1977
Site Number: 7569
Phone Number:(631) 210-6603
Hours
Access
- Monday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Tuesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Wednesday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Thursday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Friday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Saturday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- Sunday:6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Office
- Monday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
- Tuesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
- Wednesday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
- Thursday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
- Friday:9:30 AM - 6:00 PM
- Saturday:9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
- Sunday:Closed
Directions
Intersections/Landmarks
Candlewood Rd and 5th Ave
Directions from the North
Drive south on Wicks Rd. Continue onto 5th Ave. Our facility will be on your left after Fairtown Rd.
Directions from the South
Drive north on 5th Ave. Pass Spur Dr N and continue north. Our facility will be on your right after Candlewood Rd.
Directions from the East
Drive west on Suffolk Ave. Turn left onto 5th Ave. Our facility will be on your left after Fairtown Rd.
Directions from the West
Drive east on Long Island Ave. Turn right onto Grant Ave. Turn left onto Pine Aire Dr. Turn right onto 5th Ave. Our facility will be on your left.
Frequently Asked Questions at 1775 5th Ave
Does 1775 5th Ave have 24 hour access self storage?
How secure are storage units at 1775 5th Ave?
What size padlock should I use for storage unit at 1775 5th Ave?
Where can I buy moving boxes at 1775 5th Ave?
Can I work out of storage units at 1775 5th Ave?
*Promotional Terms & Conditions and Size Disclaimer
Reviews
May 6, 2026
Gennari
Posted On Google
Execelente.
Response from Extra Space Storage (5/6/2026)
Agradecemos seu excelente feedback! Sua satisfação com a Extra Space Storage significa tudo para nós, Gennari.
May 4, 2026
Carla
Posted On Google
Faith was very professional answered all questions
Response from Extra Space Storage (5/4/2026)
Thank you for highlighting Faith's professionalism and helpfulness. We're pleased she answered all your questions effectively, Carla.
May 4, 2026
neilwazhere
Posted On Google
Great experience overall—facility was clean, secure, and easy to access. Pricing was fair with no surprises. Faith was friendly and super helpful!
Response from Extra Space Storage (5/5/2026)
Thanks for highlighting our clean, secure facility and Faith's helpful service. We're thrilled you found our pricing fair, Neilwazhere!
May 3, 2026
Jairo
Posted On Google
I give one star beacuse you cant give it any less... this place is getting worst every day, 2 of the entrances are most of the times broken, the whole place is filthy... theyre quick to call you when is due date lol on top of that they raise the rent 2 or 3 moths. The only reason they have lots of 5 stars is beacuse they literally make you give them 5 stars when you get the unit
Response from Extra Space Storage (5/4/2026)
We apologize for falling short with broken entrances and cleanliness issues, Jairo. Please contact us at (631) 210-6603 to discuss these concerns directly.
May 2, 2026
TheroneShellman
Posted On Google
I lost the keys to the storage lock and so I called the office and let them know I would come in the following morning. Once they opened in the morning I went inside the office and let Faith know about my situation. She was very polite and directed me to signing an online release form. She went and grabbed a drill and we walked to my storage. I didn't have a regular lock which hangs on the outside. The one I had was a circular lock which you place inside the lock area and it locks in when you turn the key. This type lock goes inside and so you cannot use a bolt cutter. Faith was very patient and it took three drill bids, and two, three batteries, as well as a flat head screw driver and hammer to get the lock out. It took some time and grit, but Faith was patient and good spirited the whole time. I wanted to help, but she told me she had it, and she did. I appreciated her assistance because she could of just given up and called a locksmith after a little bit of time. She stayed with it and got the job done. I was sorry to have caused so much work, but at the same time appreciative. Five stars in every category for Faith over at the 5th Avenue location.
Response from Extra Space Storage (5/3/2026)
Thanks for recognizing Faith's dedication and persistence. We're proud she went above and beyond to help with your lock situation. It's wonderful to hear that Faith was so patient and good-spirited throughout the entire process, especially considering how challenging it was to remove that circular lock with multiple drill bits and batteries. Her commitment to seeing the job through instead of giving up and calling a locksmith really demonstrates the level of service we strive to provide at our 5th Avenue location. We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and highlight Faith's exceptional assistance during what could have been a very frustrating situation.
