Deciding between moving to Chicago or New York City? Whether you choose the Windy City or the Big Apple, these incredible destinations are some of the best places in the U.S. for those seeking a big-city lifestyle. We compared Chicago and NYC based on cost of living, things to do, lifestyle, and more to help you determine which is right for you. Read this guide to learn more about living in Chicago or New York City!
Should You Move to Chicago or New York City?
Chicago and New York City are two of the most iconic cities in the U.S., and the best choice for you depends on your lifestyle and budget. If you’re drawn to fast-paced energy, career opportunities in finance and fashion, and a city that never sleeps, New York City might be your ideal destination. It offers extensive public transit, renowned cultural institutions, and a global atmosphere. Chicago is a less densely populated big city with a passionate local culture. It’s known for its impressive architecture, vibrant arts scene, and Midwestern charm. Chicago is great if you’re looking for a slightly slower pace and more affordable cost of living without sacrificing opportunity.
Consider the Cost of Living in Chicago vs. New York City
Chicago and New York City are two of the largest cities in the U.S.—and with that comes a higher cost of living. However, the overall expenses and the factors that help offset them look different in each city. Comparing how far your dollar goes in Chicago vs. New York can give you a clearer idea of which city best fits your budget and lifestyle.
Find Affordable Housing in Chicago
While you might expect the Windy City to break the bank, the cost of living in Chicago is only 14% higher than the national average, making it reasonably affordable for a major city. Housing costs, in particular, are significantly lower than in NYC. Plus, Chicago residents benefit from a median household income that is 12% higher than the U.S. average, making an urban lifestyle more realistic—and those seeking budget assistance can take advantage of the city’s affordable rental housing resources. If you’re hoping to buy a home instead, Chicago generally has a more accessible housing market than NYC, which may play a role in your decision of where to move. Some of the best places to buy a home in Chicago include neighborhoods like Mount Greenwood, Beverly, and The Loop.
Enjoy a High-End Lifestyle in NYC
It’s no secret that New York City regularly ranks as one of the most expensive places to live in the U.S.—the cost of living in NYC is 69% higher than the national average. But while New York City’s living costs surpass Chicago’s, it justifies this with unmatched access to culture, recreation, and job opportunities. Additionally, there are five major boroughs—The Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, and Staten Island—with each offering varied costs of living to fit different budgets. In addition, the median household income in NYC is 21% higher than the U.S. average, helping offset the city’s high housing costs. Settling down in safe, affordable NYC neighborhoods like Kensington, Prince’s Bay, and Jackson Heights can also help stretch your budget, making it easier to enjoy all the amenities and opportunities the Big Apple has to offer.
Q: What is the cost of living in NYC vs. Chicago?A: Chicago is significantly more affordable than New York City, with an overall cost of living that’s roughly 39% lower. It should be noted, however, that NYC’s median household income is about $5,000 more than Chicago’s, which helps offset costs.
Find Employment in Chicago & NYC
While Chicago has a higher focus on manufacturing and healthcare, New York City is a beacon for financial institutions and tech. Despite their differences, each offers incredible career opportunities.
Discover Diverse Career Options in Chicago
Chi-Town is considered one of the best cities for young professionals, thanks to its higher income and access to excellent job opportunities. Some key industries in Chicago include food innovation, transportation, healthcare, technology, and manufacturing. The city is also home to over a dozen Fortune 500 companies, including Exelon, Kraft Heinz, and McDonald’s. Find work at some of the best companies in Chicago with law firms Baker McKenzie or Winston & Strawn. Get started with a manufacturing career in Chicago at Tropicana Brand Group, Ryerson, or JBT FoodTech. Passionately pursue healthcare at the medical supply store Hillrom or hospital tech developer R1 RCM. Or if you’re a remote worker, coworking in Chicago is common at spaces like Rent24, WeWork, and Office Evolution.
Explore World-Class Finance, Tech, & Fashion Jobs in NYC
Boasting a lower unemployment rate than Chicago, the Big Apple is a powerful hub for all things business—with major industries in NYC focusing on finance, fashion, technology, and life sciences. In fact, New York City is commonly known as the world’s leading financial city, a status affirmed by the presence of institutions like the New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ. Some of the top finance companies in NYC include global firm KKR, investment bank Deutsche Bank, and independent investment advisor Moelis & Company. Not only is New York City home to the most Fortune 500 companies of any city—including giants like Con Edison, Goldman Sachs, and JPMorganChase—but it also hosts hundreds of tech startups and small businesses. If you’re looking to work in New York City outside finance and tech, apply at companies like the global law firm Sullivan & Cromwell, national publisher Simon & Schuster, or Broadway producer Manhattan Theatre Club. Or find fashion jobs in NYC at houses like Ralph Lauren and Michael Kors, or any of the companies in Manhattan’s Garment District.
Q: Is Chicago or New York City better for jobs?
A: While both cities offer competitive job opportunities, the best choice depends on the type of work you want and your lifestyle priorities. Chicago combines strong salaries with lower living costs and growing industries, making it attractive for many job seekers. New York City, meanwhile, offers abundant career options in sectors like finance, tech, media, and the arts.
Hop on Transit in Chicago & New York City
Although Chicago and New York City are both sprawling urban metros infamous for traffic congestion, they’re also cities where you don’t need a car—ranking among the cities with the best public transportation. Take advantage of the following options for public transit in Chicago and NYC!
Navigate Busy Chicago on the “L” Train
Moving through Chicago is simple, thanks to its smart and extensive transportation options. Navigate through eight “L” train lines and more than 100 bus routes from the Chicago Transit Authority (CTA), which connects neighborhoods across the city. For longer-distance commutes, the Metra rail system out of Chicago Union Station offers reliable service that connects Downtown Chicago and the city’s southern suburbs. Locals can also find alternative ways to get around, including Pace suburban buses, shuttle services, and even water taxis. Those who prefer driving will find plenty of public parking garages and well-maintained roads. Meanwhile, city dwellers can enjoy Chicago’s walkable neighborhoods and bike-friendly infrastructure—which includes over 60 miles of protected bike lanes as part of a 500-mile bike network, plus the Divvy bike-share program. And when you need a flight beyond the city, regional, national, and international travel is made easy with Midway International Airport and O’Hare International Airport.
Rely on the Robust NYC Subway System
Although it has a reputation for high traffic, New York City has one of the largest public transit systems in the U.S. to help make up for it. With 55% of households having zero vehicles and a majority of residents getting around using the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), it’s recommended to go car-free in NYC. The NYC Subway is one of America’s oldest and longest subway systems, with 472 stations on 25 routes situated throughout the city. There are also roughly 6,000 NYC buses that travel around 150 million miles a year. Partnering with MTA, the NYC Department of Transportation (DOT) built 20 Select Bus Service routes and 75 express bus routes in the five boroughs to provide faster, more reliable bus service for commuters. If you’re heading to significant New York destinations like Staten Island and Ellis Island, travel more than 60 nautical miles along the East River on the NYC Ferry. Or book a flight to travel around and outside of the U.S. at one of the three major NYC-area airports—John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), LaGuardia Airport (LGA), or Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR).
Q: What are the commute times in Chicago vs. New York City?
A: The average commute time in Chicago is 35 minutes, compared with 40 minutes in New York City. Residents can help circumvent traffic congestion and longer commutes by using each city’s transit systems and real-time apps and alerts.
Sign Up for Classes at Colleges in Chicago & New York City
These two major cities have no shortage of renowned universities and higher education opportunities. Discover the best colleges in Chicago and NYC to see which city is most suited to your educational goals.
Attend Top Universities in Chicago
Chicago is home to dozens of colleges and universities, giving ample opportunity to develop critical skills in your favorite field of study. Earn a degree in Chicago in popular majors like economics, computer science, and mathematics from the University of Chicago, one of the best colleges in the U.S. Choose from 94 undergraduate degrees and 84 minors, including architecture, engineering, and life sciences at the University of Illinois Chicago, where Illinois families earning under $75K qualify for free tuition. Get a 2-year degree at Harry S Truman College, Harold Washington College, or other Chicago community colleges in the City Colleges of Chicago system. Enroll at the largest Catholic university in the U.S. to pursue programs like entrepreneurship, game design, and finance at DePaul University. Study law, medicine, and business programs at Loyola University Chicago, a Jesuit school. Or earn your master’s or PhD with excellent STEM programs like advanced manufacturing, applied mathematics, and applied cybersecurity and digital forensics at the Illinois Institute of Technology.
Find the Right College in New York City
Not only are there great colleges in NYC, but the state of New York itself is home to over 130 universities, the most of any state in the U.S.! Develop skills in economics, computer science, and political science at the prestigious Ivy League Columbia University. Get involved with performing arts, social sciences, and management on the Manhattan or Brooklyn campus of New York University. Find higher education in The Bronx by studying from 70 undergraduate majors at the private Jesuit Fordham University. Graduate with a degree in popular fields like psychology, biological sciences, and liberal arts at The City College of New York, one of the best public colleges in New York City. If you’re interested in fashion, find a home at top fashion schools in NYC like the Fashion Institute of Technology, the Parsons School of Design at The New School, and LIM College. And artists, architects, and designers can get a worthwhile education at the Pratt Institute.
Q: Does Chicago or New York City have the best colleges?
A: Which city has the best colleges depends on your field of study. Chicago is known for strong programs in law and STEM, while New York City offers specialized options like top fashion, art, and design schools. Both cities are home to some of the best colleges in the U.S.
Enjoy Outdoor Recreation in Chicago & New York City
Although nicknames like the Windy City and Concrete Jungle don’t evoke thoughts of lush parks and green spaces, Chicago and NYC actually both have similar climates and an abundance of outdoor recreation spots and activities to explore. Discover more below!
Relax Along Lake Michigan in Chicago
Chicago experiences a wide range of weather, from hot summers to cold winters—though Lake Michigan helps moderate extreme temperatures. While the city occasionally faces severe weather like thunderstorms and tornadoes, it isn’t actually one of the windiest cities despite its famous nickname. With proper preparation, Chicago’s varied climate provides great opportunities for outdoor recreation in all four seasons. Spend a day admiring Chicago art, scenic waterfront views, and nearby attractions at the Chicago Riverwalk. Enjoy the water with dinner and brunch cruises, thrill rides, or sightseeing tours—like the Seadog River and Lake Architecture Tour, which takes you from the Chicago River past landmarks such as Willis Tower. Sunbathe, play beach volleyball, or go kayaking and jet skiing at beautiful Lake Michigan beaches like North Avenue Beach and Margaret T. Burroughs Beach (also known as 31st Street Beach). Walk, run, or go cycling in Chicago on The 606, a once-abandoned rail line turned recreational trail. Explore nearby restaurants, listen to live music, or relax on the waterfront green space of Lincoln Park. Or take advantage of winter in Chicago by going ice skating at the iconic Millennium Park or sledding at Soldier Field.
Spend a Day at Scenic NYC Parks
Much like Chicago, NYC’s climate offers a full range of weather, with temperatures averaging between 28 and 85 degrees throughout the year. Though the city’s coastal location along the Atlantic Ocean requires residents to be prepared for occasional hurricanes and floods, New York City is great for outdoor fun. As it’s home to over 30,000 acres of parkland encompassing playgrounds, athletic fields, courts, and more, there’s no shortage of ways to enjoy some fresh air. Play sports, go fishing and kayaking, or take in sweeping views of the Hudson River from nearby piers at Brooklyn Bridge Park. Go on sightseeing and birdwatching tours, attend eclectic live events, or try out the fields and courts at Manhattan’s legendary Central Park. Visit the Bronx for golfing, hiking trails, or tours of the Bartow-Pell Mansion at Pelham Bay Park, the largest park in NYC. Trek through features like the Tiffany & Co. Foundation Overlook, 14th Street Passage, and Chelsea Market Passage at The High Line, an elevated freight line-turned-park. Spend leisure time walking boardwalks, tanning, or swimming at NYC beaches like Coney Island and Manhattan Beach. Or warm up your skating skills during winter in NYC at the timeless attraction, The Rink at Rockefeller Center.
Q: Do Chicago and New York City offer waterfront recreation?
A: Yes, both Chicago and NYC have waterfront recreation opportunities. Chicago attractions like the Chicago Riverwalk and Lake Michigan beaches offer boating, swimming, and scenic views, while NYC has waterfront fun at Brooklyn Bridge Park, Hudson River piers, and Manhattan Beach Park.
Experience Chicago & New York City Culture
Chicago and New York City are diverse metros with some of the most unforgettable attractions, rich histories, and deep community cultures in the country. Both offer countless ways to spend your day—while NYC is a hub for Broadway and pop culture, Chicago is a hotspot for incredible events and festivals.
Delve Into the Rich History of Chicago Culture
Whether you’re seeking history, arts, sports, or something more, Chi-Town has it all! Visit must-see Chicago museums, including perspective-shifting installations at the Museum of Illusions, renowned international artworks at the Art Institute of Chicago, or nearly 40 million artifacts at the Field Museum—one of the best natural history museums in the country. Navigate space-focused exhibits and stargaze at night at America’s first planetarium, the Adler Planetarium. Experience Chicago’s festivals by sampling some of the best local food and drink at events like Chicago Restaurant Week and Chicago Beer Fest. Join the crowd at Chicago music festivals each summer, like the Chicago Blues Festival, Riot Fest, and the world-famous Lollapalooza. Celebrate the city’s LGBTQ community with live music, shopping, drag shows, and a parade at Chicago Pride. Line the bleachers to see the Chicago Cubs (MLB) smash home runs out of Wrigley Field, and visit Rate Field for ninth-inning hits from the Chicago White Sox (MLB). Or get rowdy at Soldier Field for clutch touchdown passes from the Chicago Bears (NFL).
Explore Iconic New York City Venues
As one of the most diverse cities in the U.S., New York City’s population impacts its art, history, and culture. Appreciate a collection of over 490,000 works of art spanning over 5,000 years at The Metropolitan Museum of Art (MET)—the most visited museum in the U.S. Explore and learn about the natural universe with exhibitions like Cosmic Splendor, Eyes on the Universe, and Opulent Oceans at the American Museum of Natural History. Make a trip to one of 39 beautiful venues in Times Square’s Theater District to see performances like Moulin Rouge! at the Al Hirschfield Theatre, Wicked at the Gershwin Theatre, and The Great Gatsby at the Broadway Theatre. Fill your schedule with NYC festivals like the immersive Tribeca Film Festival, multi-genre music festival The Governors Ball, and New York Comic Con (NYCC), a staple film, TV, and pop culture celebration. Commemorate historic LGBTQ milestones at the NYC Pride March, one of the top pride celebrations in the U.S. Get tickets to historic Yankee Stadium to see the 27-time World Series Championship winners, the New York Yankees (MLB)—or head to Citi Field in Queens for a baseball showcase from the New York Mets (MLB). Or crowd MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford for game-winning plays from the New York Giants (NFL) or New York Jets (NFL).
Q: Are Chicago and NYC LGBTQ friendly?
A: Yes, both Chicago and New York City are LGBTQ friendly. Each city earned a perfect 100 on the Municipal Equality Index (MEI) and is home to some of the largest Pride celebrations in the U.S., attracting global visitors.
Try Delicious Food in Chicago & New York City
These two cities are often pitted against each other in the war between New York-style pizza and Chicago-style pizza. But both are top foodie cities, each with its own unique flavor. From street-style food to international fare, these destinations have it all.
Munch On Authentic Chicago Street Food
The Windy City is a food paradise with delicious street-style grub, subs and sandwiches, and the city’s famous deep-dish pizza. Bite into crispy sandwiches for lunch in Chicago with The Dearborn Burger, The Cubano, or Mushroom Melt from The Dearborn. Try a classic Chicago red hot—a style the late Anthony Bourdain called “the finest hot dog on the planet”—at popular spots like Gene & Jude’s, Portillo’s, or Redhot Ranch. Taste incredible dim sum and other Chinese food in Chicago, like the Crab Rangoon, Deep Fried Huajuan, and Marinated Jellyfish at Chinatown’s MingHin Cuisine. Visit a Chicago Greek restaurant for local classics, including the Gyros Sandwich, Charburger, and Feta Pita at the family-owned Athenian Room. Pull out a chair for authentic Italian eats, such as Shrimp Risotto, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Orecchiette from Quartino Ristorante. Discover some of the best deep-dish pizza in Chicago with mouthwatering slices from Gino’s East, Lou Malnati’s, and Pequod’s Pizza. Or find vegan-friendly options like The Florence Ballard, Vegan Cheese, and Vegan Sausage pizza from Lincoln Square’s Dimo’s Pizza.
Taste Worldwide Flavors in NYC
There are over 15,000 restaurants in NYC, meaning you’ll never run out of hotspots to visit, with flavors representative of every international culture. Wake up for a breakfast of New York City bagels with flavors like Jalapeno Cheddar from Liberty Bagels, Salted Pretzel from Russ & Daughters, and French Toast from Tompkins Square Bagels. Grab hot sandwiches for lunch with Katz’s Pastrami Sandwich, Katz’s Corned Beef Sandwich, and Katz’s Reuben from Katz’s Delicatessen—a famous NYC deli operating since 1888. Enjoy incredible NYC sushi and Omakase from renowned chef Daisuke Nakazawa at Sushi Nakazawa. Visit a Ukrainian restaurant in New York City for authentic specialties like Ukrainian Borscht, Varenyky, and Potato Pancakes at Veselka. Make reservations for delectable Sri Lankan cuisine like Vegetarian Lamprais and Lamb String Hopper Kottu, or enjoy a weekend buffet at Lakruwana Restaurant. Try NYC Italian food in a casual setting with Insalata di Cesare, Gnocchi alla Sorrentina, and Tonno alla Plancia con Insalata Mediterranea from Bella Blu. Or bite into some of the best pizza in New York City with slices of Fresh Mozzarella from Joe’s Pizza Broadway, the “John’s Original” from John’s of Bleecker Street, and Burrata Pie from L’Industrie Pizzeria.
Q: Is Chicago or NYC the best pizza city in America?
A: According to Food & Wine, New York City has the best pizza in the world—but whether you prefer NYC or Chicago pizza will depend on your taste. While Chicago specializes in deep-dish pizza, New York City is known for its thin, foldable slices.
Find Family Activities in Chicago & NYC
You’ll find a variety of fun things to do with family in Chicago and New York City. Whether it’s interactive educational experiences or stopping by local zoos, see what these large U.S. cities have to offer families.
Raise Your Family in Chicago
Chicago is a great city for families, with top-notch schools and plenty of kid-friendly activities. Plus, some of the best neighborhoods in Chicago for families—such as Beverly, Edison Park, and Forest Glen—offer walkable streets, green spaces, and tight-knit communities. Enroll your kids in highly-rated elementary schools like Skinner North Classical School and Abraham Lincoln Elementary School, or in top Chicago high schools like Walter Payton College Preparatory High School and Lane Tech College Prep. Bring little ones for events like Dolphins in Action or Hamill Family Wild Encounters at Brookfield Zoo, or experience Jamaican Iguana Care, Monkey Cognition, and Seal Training and Feeding activities at the free Lincoln Park Zoo. Spark your child’s interest in the aquatic animal world with stunning all-ages exhibits like Experience Evolution, Wonder of Water, or Amazon Rising at the Shedd Aquarium. Chow down on delicious food and drink, step into the immersive Butterfly House, or ride the Centennial Wheel at Navy Pier. Let your kids have fun while learning from permanent exhibits like Adventures in Art, City on the Move, and Cooperation Station at the Kohl Children’s Museum. Or explore imaginative exhibits like Water City, Cloud Buster, and the Pritzker Playspace at the Chicago Children’s Museum.
Visit Family-Friendly New York City Attractions
Raising a family in New York City can present its challenges, but there are also endless opportunities that make NYC living worthwhile for families with kids. Parents will find no shortage of excellent local schools, including The Anderson School, Stuyvesant High School, and Edison Academy Magnet School. Certain family-friendly NYC neighborhoods—such as Forest Hills, Battery Park City, and Riverdale—stand out for their excellent education opportunities, safe environments, and vibrant community events and attractions. Ride the Bug Carousel, take a Nature Trek, or experience Wild Encounters with your kids’ favorite animals at the Bronx Zoo, one of the largest zoos in the U.S. Other borough-specific NYC zoos also offer incredible family fun—encounter red pandas and dingos on the Discovery Trail at Prospect Park Zoo, see beautiful cattle egrets and blue and gold macaws in the Queens Zoo‘s aviary, or celebrate seasonal events like Spooktacular at Staten Island Zoo. Let your kids learn and play with educational exhibits like PlayWorks, Dynamic H20, and Adventures with Dora and Diego at the Children’s Museum of Manhattan. See an unforgettable Aquatheater show, get close to marine snails and horseshoe crabs, or have a penguin encounter at the New York Aquarium. Or take your family to historic New York City landmarks, including the Empire State Building and nearby Ellis Island‘s Statue of Liberty.
Q: Are New York City and Chicago good places to raise a family?
A: Yes, both cities have desirable attributes for families. Chicago has great local schools, plenty of activities, and walkable streets in safe neighborhoods. The Big Apple, while busy, can also be a great place to raise a family, thanks to its diverse neighborhoods and strong educational and cultural institutions.
Explore Nightlife in Chicago & New York City
Young professionals will find an abundance of exciting things to do at night in both of these big cities. While Chicago’s nightlife scene is dominated by breweries, bars, and a flourishing comedy and improv scene, NYC nightlife is more centered around live music, nightclubs, and large events. See what each has to offer!
Visit Chicago Breweries & Comedy Clubs
Chicago’s nightlife makes it one of the best cities for singles due to its comedy clubs, lounges, and vibrant bar and brewery scene—the city even ranks among the top U.S. cities for beer. Visit Chicago’s “Malt Row” for a selection of drafts, including a Boat Shoes Kolsch, Ducks Fly Together Lager, and Birds of Paradise American Pale Ale from the local staple Begyle Brewing. Try the Anti-Hero IPA, Cold Time Premium Lager, and Fist City Pale Ale in the taproom of Revolution Brewing, Illinois’ largest craft brewery that’s independently owned. Sip fresh beverages from Chicago brewers like Around The Bend Beer, Burnt City Brewing, and Twisted Hippo at West Loop’s District Brew Yards. Relax into the night with tropical cocktails like the Jet Pilot, Saturn, and Pearl Diver at Three Dots and a Dash. Take a seat for live music and entertainment while eating Short Rib Ragu or a Smash Burger while drinking an Odd Bird Cocktail at the Prohibition-inspired Untitled Supper Club. Laugh at side-splitting comedy acts and see interactive shows like the Tomato Throw Show and Crowd Work Wednesday at The Comedy Bar. Or brighten up with hilarious stand-up acts at other top Chicago comedy clubs like The Second City, iO Theater, and Zanies.
Have Fun with High-Energy NYC Nightlife
When the sun goes down, lights get bright for big-time events in the city that never sleeps! Get tickets to headlining acts like Dua Lipa and Eric Clapton, or attend primetime games from the New York Knicks (NBA) or New York Rangers (NHL) at Madison Square Garden (MSG), “The World’s Most Famous Arena”! Attend a sold-out show with nationally-recognized artists like Shawn Mendes, Tyler Childers, and Chappell Roan at Queens’ Forest Hills Stadium. Dance at a New York City nightclub with energetic acts like Whineology, James Patterson, and Planet Yes in the Onyx Room at House of Yes. Enjoy rock and blues in a laid-back setting while drinking a Shock Top, Coney Island Pilsner, or Red Lion Amber at The Red Lion in Greenwich Village. Sip Espresso Martinis, Frozen Margaritas, and Raspberry Mojitos while taking in breathtaking NYC skyline views on the patio at 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar. Bring your friends to perform group karaoke while drinking Sangria, a Gator Glow Goblet, or an Agave Heatwave at Space Karaoke Bar & Lounge. Or stop into various themed rooms like Lafayette’s Hideout Bar, The Piano Bar Upstairs, or Independence Bar within Fraunces Tavern, the oldest bar in New York City.
Q: Is Chicago nightlife or New York City nightlife better for young professionals?
A: Chicago is great for singles and beer lovers, with its extensive brewery scene, laid-back bars, and vibrant comedy clubs. NYC, on the other hand, is all about high-energy events, live music, and iconic venues, perfect for those who thrive on diverse entertainment and variety.
***
Thinking of moving to New York City or Chicago? With convenient storage facilities throughout both Chicago and New York City, Extra Space Storage can help with your transition. Find a storage unit near you!
