Considering living in Buffalo? Among the best cities to buy real estate, bustling and affordable U.S. city Buffalo has plenty of neighborhoods to offer for residents of all age groups—from young professionals to retirees. Considering factors like safety, budget-friendly housing, and nearby amenities, we’ve determined the top five safe, affordable neighborhoods in Buffalo. Read more below!
Is Buffalo a Safe Place to Live in 2026?
Buffalo is a large city in New York with varying neighborhood crime rates. While the city is 11% safer than other New York cities, there are a variety of safe neighborhoods in the area—including Allentown, Elmwood Village, and Park Meadow—making it easy to find a safe and affordable area to live!
Allentown
- Home Price: $257,525 median purchase price; $716 median monthly rent
- Crime Rate: Safer than 9% of New York cities
- Perfect For: Students, singles, young professionals, families
Located north of Downtown Buffalo and named after farmer and businessman Lewis F. Allen, Allentown is an affordable, attractive neighborhood for young professionals and families. The LGBTQ-friendly neighborhood is the hub of Buffalo’s thriving arts community, where you can find numerous murals and brightly-painted Victorian, Italianate, Queen Anne-style houses. You can support the local art community by attending Visioning Workshops, the Allen West Festival, First Friday Gallery Walk, or the Annual College Street Block Party. The neighborhood also offers easy access to the University at Buffalo (Downtown Campus) and D’Youville University, making it an ideal option for students.
Things to Do in Allentown
Enroll your child in a musical theatre workshop, sign up for camp, or take the family to see Diary of A Wimpy Kid The Musical at Theatre of Youth. Sip a cocktail, dance to live music, or sing your heart out during karaoke at Tudor Lounge. See live acts like Roseanne Cash, Steve Hackett, and Hot Tuna at Kleinhans Music Hall. Go on a guided tour with friends, go on a double-decker bus tour, or attend events like “We The People” at the TR Inaugural Site. Start out your day with Avocado toast, Biscuits & Gravy, or a Breakfast Sandwich from Billy Club. Enjoy authentic Mexican dishes like Octopus Tostada, Pork Taquitos, and Al Pastor Tacos at Casa Azul. Try Lamb Meatballs, Charred Octopus, or Berkshire Pork Chop at Beacon Grille. Or feast on a Ribeye Steak, Julienne Salad, or Chicken Caprese Sandwich from Gabriel’s Gate.
Q: Is it expensive to live in Buffalo?
A: The cost of living in Buffalo is well below the New York and national averages, making Buffalo a reasonably affordable place to live. With the average housing and rent prices below state and national averages, you can find a variety of affordable housing options in Buffalo.
Elmwood Village
- Home Price: $325,714 median purchase price; $920 median rent
- Crime Rate: Safer than of 70% New York cities
- Perfect For: Students, singles, young professionals, families, retirees
Elmwood Village is located in the heart of Buffalo, offering plenty of access to bars, restaurants, and coffee shops. This neighborhood is particularly great for small business owners, as the Elmwood Village Association offers local support through its business membership program on top of the supportive businesses in the Elmwood Strip! And if you’re looking to further your education, Buffalo State University is a few minutes north. For families with kids, Elmwood Village offers a number of private schools, including the all-girls Nardin Academy and all-boys Canisius High School. And everyone can enjoy community events like Porchfest, the Bidwell Concert Series, Elmwood Village Farmers Market, and Buffalo Pride Parade.
Things to Do in Elmwood Village
Find your next read, meet local authors, or attend a Talking Queer Books event at Talking Leaves…Books. Immerse yourself in Buffalo’s art scene by visiting exhibits like Northern Lights, One With Eternity: Yayoi Kusama, and Adam Fuss: Visual Resonance at the nearby Buffalo AKG Art Museum. Play a round of mahjong, rubber bridge, or attend the weekly book club at The Garret Club. Try authentic Indian food like Tikka Masala, Potato Samosa, and Saag Paneer from Parivaar Pub. Enjoy high-quality Japanese dishes like Katsu-Don, Gyoza Dumplings, and Spicy Miso Ramen at SATO. Order Spanish-inspired cuisine like Spanish Wedge, Octopus Carpaccio, and Seafood Rice at Iron Tail Tavern. Enjoy fresh, authentic Italian dishes like Fettuccini Vongole, Salmon Puttanesca, and Pompelmo Insalata at JT’s Urban Italian Restaurant. And sip cocktails like Havana Moon, The Red Thread, and Music For A Sushi Restaurant at High Violet.
Q: What is Buffalo’s crime rate?
A: Buffalo is 11% safer than other cities in New York. With a variety of safe neighborhoods to live in—such as Elmwood Village and Park Meadow—you can find a safe place for you or your family to reside.
Park Meadow
- Home Price: $268,100 median purchase price; $1,037 median rent
- Crime Rate: Safer than 63% of New York cities
- Perfect For: Singles, young professionals, families, retirees
With its affordable, large, historic homes—including Tudor, Victorian, and Bungalow housing styles—and low crime rates, it’s no wonder why Park Meadow is one of the safest neighborhoods in Buffalo! Park Meadow has a booming educational system—with schools like Nichols School, McKinley High School, and Tapestry Charter School within the neighborhood. Its central location near Downtown Buffalo makes it a perfect neighborhood for commuters and workers. Plus, Park Meadow has easy access to Delaware Park, Buffalo’s largest park—and home to the Buffalo Zoo and Hoyt Lake. And families and nature lovers can enjoy the flora and fauna of gardens like Olmsted Butterfly Garden and Tapestry School Garden.
Things to Do in Park Meadow
View the lilacs, cherry blossoms, and crabapples at the nearby Japanese Garden. Attend a Story Time or Comic Book Bash, browse the ongoing book sale, or participate in a reading contest at North Park Branch Library. Explore exhibits like The Native American Gallery, The John R. Oishei Pioneer Gallery, and Continuum: A History of Erie County at The Buffalo History Museum, conveniently located near Park Meadow. Enjoy the 33 rose beds, which include pink roses, white roses, and yellow roses, at the Delaware Park Rose Garden. Start your day off with hearty breakfast items like Eggs Benedict, Ham and Cheese Omelet, and French Toast Casserole at The Garage Bar & Restaurant. Feast on Chicken Milanese, Steak Sandwich, and Prime N.Y. Strip at Oliver’s. Chow down Fried Eggplant, Fishwife Smoked Rainbow Trout, and Spanish Potato Salad at Moriarty Meats & Cafe. Or devour Ahi Tuna Nachos, Chorizo & Clams, or Chicken & Brie at The Terrace at Delaware Park.
Q: What is the safest place to live in Buffalo?
A: There are a variety of safe places to live in Buffalo. Based on crime rates, Park Meadow is one of Buffalo’s safest neighborhoods—with the area being 73% safer than other Buffalo neighborhoods.
Tonawanda
- Home Price: $119,100 median purchase price; $697 median rent
- Crime Rate: Safer than 71% of New York cities
- Perfect For: Singles, young professionals, families, retirees
Located near the Niagara River, Tonawanda’s affordable ranch, Bungalow, Craftsman, and American Foursquare-style housing—plus its middle-class suburban feel—makes it an attractive suburb for young adults and families alike. Travel is made easier through access to the Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority (NFTA) bus system, which is a bonus for commuters, and families can send their kids to schools like Tonawanda Elementary School and Tonawanda Middle School. And with annual events like the Community Farmers Market, Canal Fest, and It’s A Wonderful Night, residents grow a strong sense of community!
Things to Do in Tonawanda
Go boating, enjoy a run along the trail, or have a picnic with friends at Niawanda Park. Enjoy a live concert, musical-inspired performances, or stop by the food trucks at Gateway Harbor. Go moonlight bowling, book a birthday party, or sign your child up for a junior bowling league at Tonawanda Bowling Center. Enjoy a painting night with friends, host a party, or enjoy a magic show at Canvas Crashers. Enjoy a wide range of donuts like Apple Fritter, Maple Bacon, and Toasted Coconut at Donut Kraze. Savor a Stinger Sub, Nacho Grande, or Triple Cheese Steak Pizza at Colosso Taco & Pizza Express. Try Crabmeat Fried Rice, Shrimp Chow Mein, or Moo Goo Gai Pan at Beijing Garden. Feast on a hearty Mushroom Swiss Burger, Italian Sausage Sandwich, or Eggplant Parm Sandwich at Joey’s Place.
Q: What is the most affordable neighborhood in Buffalo?
A: With the cost of living and average housing prices being below the city and national averages, residents of Buffalo can enjoy affordable living. Tonawanda, for example, is among the most affordable neighborhoods, with a median housing price of $119,100 and a median rent of $697.
West Seneca
- Home Price: $157,400 median purchase price; $875 median rent
- Crime Rate: Safer than 69% of New York cities
- Perfect For: Singles, young professionals, families, retirees
West Seneca is a southeastern NY suburb with that offers residents a unique place to live in the Buffalo metro! The West Seneca Art Society fosters the local art scene through annual vendor showcases and fine arts shows, and annual events like the Queen of Heaven Carnival, West Seneca Farmers Market, and BurchFest make it a fun place to connect with other residents—not to mention the variety of parks, restaurants, and mom-and-pop shops, like Nut-tos and Nick Charlap’s Ice Cream! Find a mix of American Foursquare, bungalow, and ranch-style housing alongside schools like Queen of Heaven School, West Middle School, and West Senior High School. And, if you need to commute, you can use the convenient access to I-90 and the Aurora Expressway.
Things to Do in West Seneca
Play basketball with friends, have a picnic, or go on a walk at Veterans Park. Enjoy a Moison Canadian, attend a themed party, or go to a tap takeover with friends at Ebenezer Ale House. Dance to live music, attend an open mic night, or enjoy a beer at Rockin’ Buffalo Saloon. Walk along the trail, explore art gallery exhibits like Elizabeth Leader, and enjoy the flora and fauna of the park at the Charles E. Burchfield Nature & Art Center. Begin your day with breakfast items like Belgian Waffles, Steak & Eggs, and Corned Beef Hash and Eggs at Christes. Try German-inspired dishes like Fish Sandwich, Hand Carved Roast Beef, and Roast Beef Sandwich on Kummelweck at Schwabl’s. Enjoy classic Italian cuisine like Fettuccine Alfredo, Tuscan Salad, and Eggplant Parmigiana at Pasquale’s Italian Restaurant. Get a serving of ice cream with mix-in flavors like Apple Pie, Reese’s Pieces, and Cookie Dough from Kone King.
Q: What is a livable salary in Buffalo?
A: The ideal livable salary in Buffalo will depend on your employment, living situation, and lifestyle. For example, the average living wage for a single adult is $21.74 an hour, while a family may need a living wage of anywhere between $22 to $64 an hour.
***
Moving to Buffalo soon? Extra Space Storage has facilities conveniently located across the city and in the U.S. to make your transition easier. Find affordable self storage in Buffalo!
The Extra Space Storage team is committed to helping people find the perfect place to call home no matter what stage of life they’re at. Our “Best Places to Live” picks, are designed to make moving easier by providing accurate and comprehensive information on various metro areas across the country. We consider factors like cost of living, job opportunities, local attractions, education, and more to help those looking to move make an informed decision. Discover more about our methodology today.
Neighborhood & suburb statistics from AreaVibes
