Self Storage in Middle Island, NY: Find Storage Units Near You!

Extra Space Storage in Middle Island strives to provide high-quality storage solutions to residents of Middle Island and the nearby communities of Gordon Heights, Ridge, Yaphank, and more!

17 locations near middle island

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

First Month Free*

$61

Medium

10' x 9'

First Month Free*

$124

Large

10' x 20'

First Month Free*

$246

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

4' x 4'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$19

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$122

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$225

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$54

Medium

10' x 15'

Flash Sale

$127

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$199

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

Flash Sale

$28

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$77

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$280

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$68

Medium

10' x 10'

Flash Sale

$119

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$359

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$39

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$142

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$289

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 4'

$29

Medium

10' x 10'

$105

Large

10' x 20'

$313

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

6' x 8'

Flash Sale

$37

Medium

6' x 16'

Flash Sale

$64

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$246

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$35

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$119

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$273

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$46

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$102

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$344

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$61

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$222

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$462

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$57

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$111

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$272

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$40

Medium

10' x 15'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$123

Large

10' x 25'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$312

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$43

Medium

10' x 10'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$107

Large

10' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$277

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$24

Medium

5' x 20'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$183

Large

10' x 30'

$50 Moving Truck Credit

$520

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$65

Medium

9' x 9'

$138

Large

10' x 20'

Flash Sale

$184

See all available units at this facility

Extra Space Storage logo

Small

5' x 5'

$44

Medium

10' x 10'

$135

Large

10' x 20'

$263

See all available units at this facility

$19
$54
$28
$68
$39
$29
$37
$35
$46
$61
$57
$40
$43
$24
$65
$44
$61

Why Choose Extra Space Storage

Our friendly, professional team of storage experts strives to give each customer the best possible experience. The Extra Space Storage staff works hard to keep our Middle Island storage facilities clean, well-lit, and well-maintained. We also take the safety of you and your items seriously, which is why we use cutting-edge security features like video surveillance and electronic gate access.

Available Storage Units in Middle Island

Our Middle Island storage units range in size from 25 square feet to 300+ square feet, and provide convenient storage features such as drive-up access, indoor access, elevator access, and first-floor access. If you're unsure which unit size is right for you, our team is happy to help!

Affordable Prices & Great Move-In Deals

If you're searching for affordable Middle Island storage, Extra Space Storage has you covered. In addition to our competitive rental rates, we also offer fantastic move-in deals like first month free and first month half-off.

Reserve Middle Island Self Storage Today!

Ready to reserve self storage in Middle Island? Reserve today online or by phone with no credit card required!

*Excludes administrative and insurance fees

Frequently Asked Questions at Middle Island

Do I need insurance to rent a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

Can I live in a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

Do I have to sign a lease to get a storage unit in Middle Island?

Can I work out in a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

Are packages accepted at storage units in Middle Island?