Find Storage

Self Storage in Middle Island, NY: Find Cheap Storage Units Near You!

Extra Space Storage provides quality self storage in Middle Island, also serving the nearby communities of Gordon Heights, Ridge, Yaphank, and more. W...
Extra Space Storage provides quality self storage in Middle Island, also serving the nearby communities of Gordon Heights, Ridge, Yaphank, and more. With high-quality storage solutions with drive-up access, climate control, and more, we're the self storage partner you can rely on!

29 locations near middle island Found

Features
Self Storage Filters
CLEAR
Sort: Distance
Sort
Extra Space Storage facility at 901 Middle Country Rd - Middle Island, NY
0.8 mi
901 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island NY, 11953
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Elevator Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
  • Indoor
Starting at$279
0.8 MI

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$279

Vehicle

10' x 10'

Flash Sale

$97

Vehicle

5' x 5'

$39

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$263

See available units & prices at this facility

Save up to 50% off on Extra Space near you!

Savings reflected in rates.

Contrast Banner Icon
Extra Space Storage facility at 2025 Route 112 - Coram, NY
3.1 mi
2025 Route 112
Coram NY, 11727
  • Indoor
  • Lift Access
  • Outdoor Parking
  • RV Parking
  • Reduced Height
Starting at$108
3.1 MI

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$108

Vehicle

4' x 4'

$14

Vehicle

8' x 25'

$74

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 14 Francis Mooney Dr - Ridge, NY
4.1 mi
14 Francis Mooney Dr
Ridge NY, 11961
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
  • Indoor
  • Lift Access
Starting at$100
4.1 MI

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$100

Vehicle

5' x 5'

Flash Sale

$48

Vehicle

10' x 30'

Flash Sale

$217

Vehicle

10' x 30'

Flash Sale

$217

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 1027 Horseblock Rd - Farmingville, NY
4.8 mi
1027 Horseblock Rd
Farmingville NY, 11738
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
  • Multi-Door Unit
  • Outdoor Parking
  • RV Parking
Starting at$249
4.8 MI

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$249

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$146

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$127

Vehicle

5' x 5'

$37

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 970 Waverly Ave - Holtsville, NY
6.8 mi
970 Waverly Ave
Holtsville NY, 11742
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Indoor
  • Multi-Door Unit
Starting at$164
6.8 MI

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$164

Vehicle

5' x 5'

$35

Vehicle

10' x 30'

$401

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 2626 Middle Country Rd - Centereach, NY
8.2 mi
2626 Middle Country Rd
Centereach NY, 11720
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
Starting at$209
8.2 MI

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$209

Vehicle

5' x 10'

Flash Sale

$86

Vehicle

10' x 25'

$423

Vehicle

10' x 25'

$423

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 500 Sunrise Hwy - Patchogue, NY
8.3 mi
500 Sunrise Hwy
Patchogue NY, 11772
  • 1st Floor Access
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
  • Outdoor Parking
  • RV Parking
Starting at$95
8.3 MI

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$95

Vehicle

5' x 5'

$30

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$241

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$99

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 510 Johnson Ave - Bohemia, NY
10.4 mi
510 Johnson Ave
Bohemia NY, 11716
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
Starting at$25
10.4 MI

Vehicle

5' x 5'

$25

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$163

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$266

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$266

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 1590 Lakeland Ave - Bohemia, NY
10.8 mi
1590 Lakeland Ave
Bohemia NY, 11716
  • Climate Controlled
  • Elevator Access
  • Indoor
  • Outdoor Parking
  • Outdoor/No Drive-Up
  • RV Parking
Starting at$162
10.8 MI

Vehicle

10' x 10'

$162

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$336

Vehicle

5' x 5'

$32

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$128

See available units & prices at this facility

Extra Space Storage facility at 1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy - Islandia, NY
12.9 mi
1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy
Islandia NY, 11749
  • Drive-Up Access
  • Enclosed Vehicle Storage
  • Outdoor Parking
  • RV Parking
Starting at$59
12.9 MI

Vehicle

7' x 20'

$59

Vehicle

10' x 20'

$239

Vehicle

6' x 16'

$117

Vehicle

4' x 10'

$42

See available units & prices at this facility

‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌
‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌

Storage types available near Middle Island, New York

Business Storage in Middle Island
Climate-Controlled Storage
Car & Vehicle Storage
RV & Boat Storage

Why Extra Space Storage?

At Extra Space Storage, our friendly, professional team of storage experts strives to give each customer the best possible experience. Working hard to keep our Middle Island storage facilities clean, well-lit, and secure, you can trust us to meet your storage needs.

Middle Island Self Storage Features & Amenities

Our Middle Island storage units range in size from 25 square feet to 300+ square feet, also providing convenient storage features like drive-up access, indoor access, elevator access, and first-floor access. If you're unsure which unit size or type is right for you, our team is happy to help!

Rapid Rental

Thanks to our online Rapid Rental process, you can rent your storage unit quickly and easily. Simply select your unit, fill out your paperwork and payment information, and you're done! You can start storing items as soon as you receive your unit access code.

Climate Control

If you plan to store delicate belongings, we highly recommend renting a self storage unit with climate control. This amenity typically keeps your unit between 55 and 80 degrees year-round, which can help protect your items from extreme temperature changes.

Drive-Up Access

By renting drive-up storage in Middle Island, you can pull your vehicle directly up to your unit, making loading or unloading your belongings quick and easy. It's the ultimate storage convenience!

Vehicle Storage

Need vehicle storage in Middle Island? Our enclosed drive-up storage units provide a garage-like space for storing cars, motorcycles, ATVs, and other small vehicles.

Business Storage

Our facilities provide commercial storage in Middle Island, NY. With units available in various sizes and coming with top amenities and features like climate control, business owners can find an ideal storage space for inventory, tools, company vehicles, and more.

Exceptional Security

Our Middle Island storage locations use cutting-edge security features like video surveillance and electronic gate access. We care about your valued belongings!

Extended Access Hours

We know it can be difficult to reach your unit during typical office hours. With extended access hours from 6am to 10pm, you can store with more flexibility at Extra Space Storage in Middle Island!

Frequently Asked Questions in Middle Island, NY

How much do storage units in Middle Island, NY cost?

You can expect one of our most popular sizes, like a 10x10 storage unit, to average $143 per month in Middle Island, NY. Extra Space Storage also offers larger unit sizes like 10x20, which costs $272 per month on average.

What does a 5x5 storage unit in Middle Island, NY cost?

You can expect our 5x5 storage units to start at $11 and cost up to $47 on average in Middle Island, NY.

Do I need insurance to rent a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

When renting a storage unit in Middle Island from Extra Space Storage, customers are required to have proof of insurance. For most customers, your storage unit is often covered by your homeowners insurance or renters insurance, but you can purchase self storage insurance from Extra Space Storage. The benefit of purchasing self storage insurance through Extra Space Storage in Middle Island is that our options may provide more coverage for your items and possibly help you avoid increases in your premiums over time.

Do I need climate-controlled storage in Middle Island, NY?

Storage units with climate-control in Middle Island are designed to maintain a steady humidity level and temperature of 55-80 degrees year-round. We recommend renting a climate-controlled unit to protect any temperature sensitive items from extreme heat or cold.

Can I live in a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

At Extra Space Storage in Middle Island, our facilities do not allow for customers to live in their storage unit. It's against the law for an individual to live or sleep in a storage unit.

Do I have to sign a lease to get a storage unit in Middle Island?

In order to rent a storage unit from Extra Space Storage in Middle Island, you are required to sign a lease at one of our facilities. However, our leases are month-to-month, allowing customers to rent storage for as long or as little as they need it with no long-term commitments required!

Can I work out in a storage unit in Middle Island, NY?

Extra Space Storage units in Middle Island do not allow for customers to use them as a personal gym. While we welcome our customers to store gym equipment inside of our storage units, you cannot work out in one due to liability issues.

Need additional information?

Company Information

More Information

Help

Self Storage Locations

Recently Searched Locations

Need Help?

Learn More About Extra Space Storage

Extra Space Storage Inc., headquartered in Salt Lake City, Utah, owns and/or operates over 4,000 self storage properties in 43 states, and Washington, D.C. The Company's stores comprise approximately 2.5 million storage units and over 280 million square feet of rentable space, offering customers a wide selection of affordable and conveniently located and secure storage solutions across the country, including personal storage, boat storage, RV storage and business storage. We are committed to being the most convenient, secure, and professional storage solution in your neighborhood. And it is this commitment which has enabled Extra Space Storage to become the largest storage units operator in the U.S. with over 4,000 properties across the country.

© 2006 - 2025 Extra Space Storage Inc.

Privacy Policy

Click to verify BBB accreditation and to see a BBB report.